Invest
‘You feel safe because you’re close to it’, but should you?
A Janus Henderson fund manager has issued a warning on the limitations of one index, arguing that it provides only the “illusion of safety”.
‘You feel safe because you’re close to it’, but should you?
A Janus Henderson fund manager has issued a warning on the limitations of one index, arguing that it provides only the “illusion of safety”.
Glen Finegan, head of global emerging markets equities and fund manager at Janus Henderson said in Sydney yesterday that there are limitations to the EM MSCI index.
Mr Finegan explained, “I just want to point out a weakness [with the index]. We're often defending active over passive investing in emerging markets and I want to … say that not all emerging markets are as emerging as the index might suggest.
“The index looks for where there are very large companies, rather than where future potential might lie. It certainly doesn't reflect the most dynamic parts of the world.”
For example, he argued that China is overrepresented in the index because there are a lot of large, state-owned enterprises listed on the stock market that Janus Henderson wouldn’t invest in.
“China's got some demographic challenges, ageing population, healthcare costs and the physical challenges that come with that,” Mr Finegan said.
“But look at Africa, it’s hardly represented at all in the index, but the population of the content is in the process of doubling. Nigeria is going to become the fourth largest country in the world.”
While this isn’t risk-free, Mr Finegan said those selling soap in Nigeria, beer in Kenya or supermarkets in Tanzania could be in for some good news.
“So we look for those types of companies and as a result our portfolio ends up looking very different to the index,” he said.
Continuing, Mr Finegan argued that indices nature as historical measures means they look backwards rather than forwards.
He pointed to the Mexican presence in the index in 1992. It made up 30 per cent, but a lot of the big market caps from the Mexican stocks were the result of a corrupt privatisation process.
While this meant these companies were heavily represented, they didn’t deliver good returns to shareholders, and basically “weren’t good companies”.
A year later, Mexico suffered the Tequila Crisis.
“In ‘92 that [occurred] because you were looking backwards, you weren't thinking, what about India? That's quite big. What about Africa? What about China? Russia?” Mr Finegan said.
“None of these places were even represented in the index at that time, so I think the index is going to continue to change.”
Mr Finegan described the index in 1992 as “total garbage” as a guide of where to invest money, and suspects that it was also garbage last year.
“I think it will look very different in 20 years’ time and I’d like to think our portfolios reflect the future rather than the past,” he said.
In what he labelled a “final dig” at the index, Mr Finegan said the fact that 27 per cent of it is controlled by government is also not ideal.
Living in the UK, he recognises that the NHS (National Health Service) is a great thing, but wouldn’t want to invest in it.
“That's ultimately what a lot of these state-owned enterprises are, they're government policy implementation vehicles, listed ministries and we don't want to invest in those,” Mr Finegan said.
“We want to identify dynamic, entrepreunerial, honest, aligned business people with whom we'll be able to invest alongside in the long-term.”
Concluding, he claimed that not all emerging markets are created equal, as some are more mature than their large representation suggests.
“The index gives you the illusion of safety. You feel safe because you're close to it, but you should be as far away from it as possible,” Mr Finegan said.
Property
Property hotspots for young Aussies revealed
New research from Westpac revealed that the number of first home buyers looking to enter the market has more than doubled since 2019, proving that COVID-19 continues to shape Australian home ownership...Read more
Property
Aussies swap housemates for home ownership
The number of younger Australians looking to enter the property market in the next five years has doubled, as COVID-19 restrictions sees home ownership goals increase, according to research released ...Read more
Property
Falling loan deferrals prove market recovery: REIA
The reduction in loan deferral defies doom and gloom forecasts in the property market, the Real Estate Industry of Australia has said. ...Read more
Property
Why are expats returning to property market?
Expats are returning to Australia in droves, eager to put their money into safe investments. ...Read more
Property
Stamp duty to be phased out under new proposal
The NSW government has stated that it could phase out inefficient taxes such as stamp duty as it looks to recover from the COVID-19 pandemic. ...Read more
Property
Melbourne rents continue to decline
While most capital cities recorded increases in asking rents, Melbourne continued to see declines in both houses and units, according to latest data from SQM Research. ...Read more
Property
Why investors should focus on the next 1-5 years
Investors are being urged to look beyond their own backyards into opportunities over the next one to five years. ...Read more
Property
Distressed sales fall to pre-pandemic levels
Urgent property sales have dropped back to pre-pandemic levels in most cities – proof of Australia’s continuous recovery from the effects of the COVID-19 outbreak. ...Read more
Property
Property hotspots for young Aussies revealed
New research from Westpac revealed that the number of first home buyers looking to enter the market has more than doubled since 2019, proving that COVID-19 continues to shape Australian home ownership...Read more
Property
Aussies swap housemates for home ownership
The number of younger Australians looking to enter the property market in the next five years has doubled, as COVID-19 restrictions sees home ownership goals increase, according to research released ...Read more
Property
Falling loan deferrals prove market recovery: REIA
The reduction in loan deferral defies doom and gloom forecasts in the property market, the Real Estate Industry of Australia has said. ...Read more
Property
Why are expats returning to property market?
Expats are returning to Australia in droves, eager to put their money into safe investments. ...Read more
Property
Stamp duty to be phased out under new proposal
The NSW government has stated that it could phase out inefficient taxes such as stamp duty as it looks to recover from the COVID-19 pandemic. ...Read more
Property
Melbourne rents continue to decline
While most capital cities recorded increases in asking rents, Melbourne continued to see declines in both houses and units, according to latest data from SQM Research. ...Read more
Property
Why investors should focus on the next 1-5 years
Investors are being urged to look beyond their own backyards into opportunities over the next one to five years. ...Read more
Property
Distressed sales fall to pre-pandemic levels
Urgent property sales have dropped back to pre-pandemic levels in most cities – proof of Australia’s continuous recovery from the effects of the COVID-19 outbreak. ...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
