Invest
Who’s to blame for banks not passing on savings?
Following news of an inquiry into mortgage pricing, critics have in turn hit out at the regulators as the ones at fault for the banks’ failure to pass on the entirety of the rate cuts.
Who’s to blame for banks not passing on savings?
Following news of an inquiry into mortgage pricing, critics have in turn hit out at the regulators as the ones at fault for the banks’ failure to pass on the entirety of the rate cuts.
In conversation with nestegg, Propertyology managing director Simon Pressley has explained that over-regulation of the financial industry has led to misdirected anger at Australia’s banks.
Misdirected anger
Mr Pressley said the blame for the banks not passing on a rate reduction is misdirected, saying that it should instead be directed to the financial sector regulator having made it too difficult to switch lenders.
“The ridiculous over-engineering of the loan application process has destroyed productivity and enormously diluted the competitive advantages which former generations of regulators fought so hard for Australia to have,” the managing director said.
Comparing refinancing to a “gaol cell”, Mr Pressley expressed the belief that refinancing of loans has become so complex that consumers stick with overpriced mortgages rather than renegotiating terms.
“Once a borrower acquires their loan, the system locks them in. Banks know they can get away with not passing on full rate cuts because APRA has made the refinance process more painful than pulling toenails with a pair of pliers.”
Where the banking industry places the blame
Australian Banking Association chief executive Anna Bligh also weighed in, noting no problem with ADI competition: “Whether you’re looking for a new home loan, a credit card or a transaction account, competition for a customer’s business is fiercer than it has ever been.”
The sector sentiment could be seen to echo this stance, with Westpac CEO Brian Hartzer having gone on the front foot to outline why the bank is not putting profit ahead of customers in its refusal to pass on the full rate cut.
He argued instead that it is protecting its credit rating.
According to the CEO, if the bank’s credit rating falls, the bank will have to pay more for credit, ultimately leading to higher costs for consumers.
“Westpac must also retain its double A rating,” he offered.
“This rating allows the bank to import funding at a more reasonable cost from international investors.”
“To lose it would increase the cost of our wholesale funding, which would inevitably lead to higher interest rates for our borrowers,” Mr Hartzer continued.
The government’s stance
On the other hand, the government has gone after the banks, expressing the opinion that the banks have put profits before customers in their refusal to pass on the full rate reduction.
“The banks have a lot of explaining to do,” were the words of Treasurer Josh Frydenberg, who also said “customers should vote with their feet”.
“Now, some of the smaller lenders have actually passed on this rate cut in [full],” he said.
“People should shop around, get the best deal, but also make their displeasure known to their banks because the rate cuts should be passed on in full, and that would be a good thing for consumers.”
RELATED ARTICLES
-
Trust, technology and triage: what NSW’s ‘name and shame’ signals for real estate governance
-
Vacancy is rising, demand is resilient: A case study in defending yield as Australia’s rental cycle rebalances
-
Don’t lose the deposit: A case study in stopping real estate payment fraud — and the ROI for doing it
About the author
About the author
Property
Trust, technology and triage: what NSW’s ‘name and shame’ signals for real estate governance
NSW’s latest enforcement action on real estate trust accounts isn’t a one-off embarrassment; it’s a stress test of sector governance. With licences suspended and penalties applied, the message is ...Read more
Property
Vacancy is rising, demand is resilient: A case study in defending yield as Australia’s rental cycle rebalances
After a blistering run, Australia’s rental market is loosening at the edges. Vacancy is edging up off historic lows, rent inflation is set to moderate into 2026, yet underlying demand remains ...Read more
Property
Don’t lose the deposit: A case study in stopping real estate payment fraud — and the ROI for doing it
Deposit redirection scams are quietly eroding buyer savings and agency reputations in Australia’s property market. This case study unpacks how a mid-tier real estate group redesigned its settlement ...Read more
Property
The $12m threshold: Why portfolio value, not property count, now defines Australia’s investor elite
The old yardstick of six properties as shorthand for investment success has been overtaken by a harsher reality: in today’s market, elite status is defined by balance-sheet strength, not asset countRead more
Property
From intuition to instrumentation: How a "two-stakeholder" sales playbook lifted close rates and cut cycle times
High-stakes consumer purchases are increasingly joint decisions. When one partner is under-served, deals stall. This case study follows an Australian real estate group that rebuilt its sales motion ...Read more
Property
Selling in 2025: How to spot bad agents fast—and build an ROI-first vendor playbook
In Australia’s property market, choosing the wrong listing agent isn’t just inconvenient—it’s a textbook principal–agent failure that can wipe tens of thousands off your sale outcomeRead more
Property
Selling in 2026: How to de‑risk your agent choice and protect tens of thousands at settlement
Choosing the wrong selling agent isn’t just an inconvenience — it’s a balance‑sheet risk. In a market where digital discovery is concentrated and AI is recasting how listings are priced and promoted, ...Read more
Property
Rate resilience in Australian housing: why scarce supply is overpowering monetary tightening
Australia’s housing market is defying higher borrowing costs because the binding constraint isn’t demand—it’s supply. Brokers report persistent buyer competition and investor repositioning, while ...Read more
Property
Trust, technology and triage: what NSW’s ‘name and shame’ signals for real estate governance
NSW’s latest enforcement action on real estate trust accounts isn’t a one-off embarrassment; it’s a stress test of sector governance. With licences suspended and penalties applied, the message is ...Read more
Property
Vacancy is rising, demand is resilient: A case study in defending yield as Australia’s rental cycle rebalances
After a blistering run, Australia’s rental market is loosening at the edges. Vacancy is edging up off historic lows, rent inflation is set to moderate into 2026, yet underlying demand remains ...Read more
Property
Don’t lose the deposit: A case study in stopping real estate payment fraud — and the ROI for doing it
Deposit redirection scams are quietly eroding buyer savings and agency reputations in Australia’s property market. This case study unpacks how a mid-tier real estate group redesigned its settlement ...Read more
Property
The $12m threshold: Why portfolio value, not property count, now defines Australia’s investor elite
The old yardstick of six properties as shorthand for investment success has been overtaken by a harsher reality: in today’s market, elite status is defined by balance-sheet strength, not asset countRead more
Property
From intuition to instrumentation: How a "two-stakeholder" sales playbook lifted close rates and cut cycle times
High-stakes consumer purchases are increasingly joint decisions. When one partner is under-served, deals stall. This case study follows an Australian real estate group that rebuilt its sales motion ...Read more
Property
Selling in 2025: How to spot bad agents fast—and build an ROI-first vendor playbook
In Australia’s property market, choosing the wrong listing agent isn’t just inconvenient—it’s a textbook principal–agent failure that can wipe tens of thousands off your sale outcomeRead more
Property
Selling in 2026: How to de‑risk your agent choice and protect tens of thousands at settlement
Choosing the wrong selling agent isn’t just an inconvenience — it’s a balance‑sheet risk. In a market where digital discovery is concentrated and AI is recasting how listings are priced and promoted, ...Read more
Property
Rate resilience in Australian housing: why scarce supply is overpowering monetary tightening
Australia’s housing market is defying higher borrowing costs because the binding constraint isn’t demand—it’s supply. Brokers report persistent buyer competition and investor repositioning, while ...Read more
