Invest
‘Consider your options’ when it comes to active v passive
Passive investing may appear more simple and active investing more expensive, but investors should consider their goals before deciding, the director at a financial advice firm has said.
‘Consider your options’ when it comes to active v passive
Passive investing may appear more simple and active investing more expensive, but investors should consider their goals before deciding, the director at a financial advice firm has said.
Director and client adviser at Hewison Private Wealth, Nathan Lear has said the discussion around active investment strategies and passive, or index investment strategies is more complex than matters of ease and fees, and that investors should consider their long-term goals when deciding which path to take.
Speaking to Nest Egg, he explained that the low-cost nature of index investing (wherein investment managers follow the performance of a selected index) has grown in appeal in the last 10 years.
He continued, however: “People have been a lot more willing to consider passive investing strategies.
“I think it is a concern where people perhaps might not understand [the makeup of their investments] because at the end of the day you are investing in that index which is going to be made up of whatever investments or assets or companies are in that index.
“I think a lot of people possibly don't understand what they're doing and don’t understand the risks and might just be inclined to say, ‘Okay, I'll put my money into a low-cost index fund which covers the all ordinaries index in Australia or whatever, and I don't have a sound strategy behind it.’ Which obviously we think is an issue.”
He said that there’s nothing necessarily wrong with passive investing, just as long as it ties in within an investment strategy and works towards meeting investors’ goals.
“For example, that’s an income objective where you’re entering retirement. You just then need to make sure that your approach is going to be able to pay you sufficient income which maybe it can, maybe it can’t.”
However, Mr Lear did take issue with reports that 96 per cent of active managers in the USA underperform the index, noting that this figure doesn’t take volume into account.
The director elaborated: “What I mean by that is that - let's say there's 100 fund managers, 96 of them might underperform [but the] top 4 might own 60 per cent of the market share.
“That is my issue with that kind of publicity; it's a true statement to say 96 per cent of fund managers might underperform the market but in terms of the weight of where money's invested [it’s a different story].
“If you're active investing yourself, or if you're going with an active manager, do your research. If they're not performing, obviously you're not going to keep investing with them and keep paying fees, and you'll probably relocate to another manager or another investment manager. I think that's a key message.”
Continuing, he explained that investors should have conversations with their advisers about the nature of the underlying investments in an index fund, whether they are income producing or growth investments.
He noted that active managers tend to be more expensive, but performance is also a key factor.
With this knowledge, Mr Lear argued, investors and their advisers can then consider which path will best take them where they need to go.
“We all know investing is a long-term game and sometimes, by following the herd, you can do well in the short term,” he commented.
“Bitcoin automatically comes to mind where you can make a lot of money by going with the popular investment move, or the technology companies like Google, Amazon, Apple and all of that, some of these stocks are really riding away with the moment and if you're not investing in those maybe you're underperforming.
“But there might be, and I'm not saying this is going to happen, but if there is a correction, a good manager who hasn't gotten carried away with the herd, their value will eventually be rewarded for that.”
Given this, the director said investors need to ensure that their investments, their investment decisions and the rationale behind them add up.
“Don't make a decision in a short period of time because [as they say at Hewison Private Wealth], investing is a minimum of a five-year time horizon. Sometimes certain investments can underperform in the short term but over the long term you'll be rewarded.”
Property
A generation of Aussies could be locked out of the housing market as prices boom
A booming property market is set to see a generation of younger Australians priced out of the market, a shadow assistant minister has said, challenging the narrative that younger people are failing...Read more
Property
Is the property market reaching its summit?
While home values continued to rise across the country in April, current trends are pointing to the possibility that the property market has peaked, a new report has revealed. ...Read more
Property
Wait, so it’s definitely cheaper to rent than buy?
New research has revealed that there are indeed dwellings in Australia that are cheaper to buy than rent (57 per cent to be exact), but where are these dwellings located and are they liveable? ...Read more
Property
‘List your homes before the good times run out’
Aussies who had planned to sell their house prior to the pandemic are being urged to realise those plans now, with buyers said to be immensely hungry for housing. ...Read more
Property
National house prices break 18-year record
Building on the post-pandemic recovery trend, national house prices saw the steepest quarterly increase in almost 18 years, with a majority of the capital cities witnessing record price gains. ...Read more
Property
Rents grow at fastest pace since 2007
Housing rents are rising at the fastest pace since 2007, but experts are warning that rental conditions around the country are extremely diverse. ...Read more
Property
It is now more expensive to rent in the Gold Coast than Sydney: Domain
A spike in consumer lifestyle demand means it is now more expensive to rent on the Gold Coast than in Sydney, a new industry report has revealed. ...Read more
Property
Has the property market reached its peak?
Australian property has shown exceptional strength as it rebounds post-pandemic, with the national growth rate in March beating a 33-year record. However, some experts believe it’s all downhill from...Read more
Has the property market reached its peak; Biden’s climate summit and our sharemarket, and the upcoming budget
Listen now
Is the market overheating; should ETFs take your fancy, and what’s happening to the low and middle income tax offset?
Listen now
Home values up 30% (or are they); NFTs taking the world by storm, and why Keating thinks Aussies will be ‘poor’ in retirement
Listen now
Raging floods, the tech stock bubble and the ongoing SG debate
Listen now
Property
A generation of Aussies could be locked out of the housing market as prices boom
A booming property market is set to see a generation of younger Australians priced out of the market, a shadow assistant minister has said, challenging the narrative that younger people are failing...Read more
Property
Is the property market reaching its summit?
While home values continued to rise across the country in April, current trends are pointing to the possibility that the property market has peaked, a new report has revealed. ...Read more
Property
Wait, so it’s definitely cheaper to rent than buy?
New research has revealed that there are indeed dwellings in Australia that are cheaper to buy than rent (57 per cent to be exact), but where are these dwellings located and are they liveable? ...Read more
Property
‘List your homes before the good times run out’
Aussies who had planned to sell their house prior to the pandemic are being urged to realise those plans now, with buyers said to be immensely hungry for housing. ...Read more
Property
National house prices break 18-year record
Building on the post-pandemic recovery trend, national house prices saw the steepest quarterly increase in almost 18 years, with a majority of the capital cities witnessing record price gains. ...Read more
Property
Rents grow at fastest pace since 2007
Housing rents are rising at the fastest pace since 2007, but experts are warning that rental conditions around the country are extremely diverse. ...Read more
Property
It is now more expensive to rent in the Gold Coast than Sydney: Domain
A spike in consumer lifestyle demand means it is now more expensive to rent on the Gold Coast than in Sydney, a new industry report has revealed. ...Read more
Property
Has the property market reached its peak?
Australian property has shown exceptional strength as it rebounds post-pandemic, with the national growth rate in March beating a 33-year record. However, some experts believe it’s all downhill from...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
