Invest
What does unrest in Spain mean for investors?
There may be a “cloud over Spanish assets” as the Catalan region attempts to secede, but while the situation is “marred by violence”, it’s no Brexit.
What does unrest in Spain mean for investors?
There may be a “cloud over Spanish assets” as the Catalan region attempts to secede, but while the situation is “marred by violence”, it’s no Brexit.
That’s according to AMP Capital’s chief economist, Shane Oliver, who was speaking about the 1 October referendum for Catalan independence. The referendum, declared illegal by the federal Spanish authority, had a turnout of 43 per cent. However, 90 per cent of those voters voted for independence.
Noting that most of the talk around the referendum had centred on the efforts by the Spanish government to stop it going ahead, the ensuing violence and the result, Mr Oliver said the unrest is “obviously going to be an ongoing issue”.
He continued: “Does it cause a major problem for the Eurozone and therefore for global investment markets? I don’t think so. Quite simply, the Catalonians have an issue with the rest of Spain more broadly; they don’t have an issue with the rest of Europe or the Eurozone. They don’t want to leave the Euro, in other words.”
“This is not another Brexit type thing, but obviously it does put a bit of a cloud over Spain and Spanish assets for the time being [and there’s] probably a fair way to go on this issue,” he said.
Not everyone agrees
Last week, Spanish stocks suffered one of the largest exits of investor-held Spanish equity funds since 2014.
Meanwhile, the Spanish minister of economy, Luis de Guindos warned: “The uncertainty is paralysing all investment projects in Catalonia.
“Right not, I’m convinced that there is not one single foreign or domestic investor that is going to execute a new investment project in Catalonia until this is clarified.”
He continued, noting that despite investor and business unrest in the region, the Spanish economy had suffered no national impact and is on track to grow by more than 3 per cent this year. However, should Catalonia secede from Spain, it would suffer a “brutal pauperisation”.
This warning is supported by commentary from ING economist Geoffrey Minne, who, prior to the referendum, warned: “Cultural and political motives [for secession] have been put forward but the economic benefits are far from clear. As with Brexit, we believe that any Catalexit would plunge the region into a long period of uncertainty and would most probably be negative for the private sector.”
Mr Minne said that “uncertainty alone” could impact private demand and lower external demand which could subsequently reduce job creation.
He added: “For business investment, uncertainty might even be more important than for consumers as any perception of political instability could affect foreign investment far more than local investment.”
While Mr Oliver argued that Catalan independence was “not another Brexit thing”, Mr Minne argued that the question around EU membership for a Catalan republic would also inject uncertainty into the market.
Continuing, Mr Minne contended that the possibility of a temporary currency and shaky access to international markets would mean a Catalan republic would be “an expensive project”. Those factors would be compounded by the size and allocation of public debt in Catalonia as well as the Euro-centric nature of exports and inbound foreign investment.
“The bulk of the costs that could be cut depend on the goodwill of European governments (the Spanish one included). It remains difficult to evaluate the consequences of such an unprecedented event, but in the long run we can imagine that the economic cost for Catalonia could proportionally exceed that of Brexit for the UK,” Mr Minne said.
In a word of caution to investors, Mr Oliver concluded: “Don’t forget, only about 40 per cent of the Catalonian population that could vote, did vote. So, don’t read too much into the referendum results, per se. Obviously this issue has a bit further to go, but it’s mainly a Spanish issue, it’s not a big issue for global investors or for the Eurozone.”
Property
House prices set for pre-COVID highs in early 2021
National house prices are on track to be back to pre-COVID levels by early 2021, new research has revealed. ...Read more
Property
Should Australia cancel rental debts?
Nearly 1 million tenants across Australia could be left homeless if rental debt is not forgotten when the moratorium on evictions lifts, new research has found. ...Read more
Property
Why didn’t the Australian property market crash?
Doom and gloom headlines filled the news as soon as COVID-19 outbreak began, and Australia ultimately headed to its first recession in over 28 years, but no drastic decline was seen in the housing mar...Read more
Property
Top 20 school zones for property growth
New report from Domain revealed the top 10 primary and secondary school catchment zones, all with more than a 25 per cent house price growth year-on-year. ...Read more
Property
More Aussies ‘in tears’ during house-hunting
New research has found that 9 out of 10 Australians find the process of house-hunting more frustrating than exciting, revealing the search for “the one” is filled with frustration, stress and tear...Read more
Property
Property hotspots for young Aussies revealed
New research from Westpac revealed that the number of first home buyers looking to enter the market has more than doubled since 2019, proving that COVID-19 continues to shape Australian home ownership...Read more
Property
Aussies swap housemates for home ownership
The number of younger Australians looking to enter the property market in the next five years has doubled, as COVID-19 restrictions sees home ownership goals increase, according to research released ...Read more
Property
Falling loan deferrals prove market recovery: REIA
The reduction in loan deferral defies doom and gloom forecasts in the property market, the Real Estate Industry of Australia has said. ...Read more
Property
House prices set for pre-COVID highs in early 2021
National house prices are on track to be back to pre-COVID levels by early 2021, new research has revealed. ...Read more
Property
Should Australia cancel rental debts?
Nearly 1 million tenants across Australia could be left homeless if rental debt is not forgotten when the moratorium on evictions lifts, new research has found. ...Read more
Property
Why didn’t the Australian property market crash?
Doom and gloom headlines filled the news as soon as COVID-19 outbreak began, and Australia ultimately headed to its first recession in over 28 years, but no drastic decline was seen in the housing mar...Read more
Property
Top 20 school zones for property growth
New report from Domain revealed the top 10 primary and secondary school catchment zones, all with more than a 25 per cent house price growth year-on-year. ...Read more
Property
More Aussies ‘in tears’ during house-hunting
New research has found that 9 out of 10 Australians find the process of house-hunting more frustrating than exciting, revealing the search for “the one” is filled with frustration, stress and tear...Read more
Property
Property hotspots for young Aussies revealed
New research from Westpac revealed that the number of first home buyers looking to enter the market has more than doubled since 2019, proving that COVID-19 continues to shape Australian home ownership...Read more
Property
Aussies swap housemates for home ownership
The number of younger Australians looking to enter the property market in the next five years has doubled, as COVID-19 restrictions sees home ownership goals increase, according to research released ...Read more
Property
Falling loan deferrals prove market recovery: REIA
The reduction in loan deferral defies doom and gloom forecasts in the property market, the Real Estate Industry of Australia has said. ...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
