Invest
Means-tested negative gearing under the microscope
A property research institute has suggested a means-tested approach to negative gearing, in which mum and dad investors score lower taxes than their sophisticated counterparts.
Means-tested negative gearing under the microscope
A property research institute has suggested a means-tested approach to negative gearing, in which mum and dad investors score lower taxes than their sophisticated counterparts.
However, the proposal from the Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute (AHURI) has not been received with open arms by industry players.
Responding to the AHURI report, released yesterday, the Housing Industry Association (HIA) said taxing investors is no solution to housing affordability.
AHURI suggested a means-tested approach to negative gearing, in which sophisticated investors receive less return – and as such incentive – than the ‘mum and dad’ investors.
The institute argued that this was a more politically palatable solution to the country-wide concern.
Researchers Alan Duncan, Helen Hodgson, John Minas, Rachel Ong and Richard Seymour said, “Negative gearing and CGT discount benefits are currently heavily skewed towards those who are more affluent, raising concerns around the extent to which such policies exacerbate income and wealth inequality among the Australian population.”
They continued, arguing that a “progressive rental deduction reform” in which ‘mum and dad’ investors have greater access to tax concessions than their ‘sophisticated’ counterparts based on income and wealth levels would cushion the lower-tier investors from serious financial hits.
Further, they said it would “moderate adverse impacts on their economic wellbeing in comparison to a blunt cap on rental deductions”.
“A progressive rental deduction reform has the potential to reduce inequities in the current negative gearing system by reducing tax savings by proportionately greater amounts for those with higher income or property asset levels,” the researchers said.
However, the principle economist at the HIA, Tim Reardon, disagreed.
“Any new taxes or changes to negative gearing will exacerbate the affordability challenge by discouraging investment in new housing, force up the cost of renting and make it harder for first home buyers and renters to get into a home,” he said.
“Increasing taxes on housing through additional stamp duty, means testing negative gearing or increasing capital gains tax, will create additional barriers to investing in residential property and so supply will fall.”
A fall in supply will mean prices for both renters and owner-occupiers will increase, he argued, calling for boosted supply.
“This involves adequate release of land for new dwellings including increasing the density of housing in metropolitan areas.
“Increasing the tax imposed on rental housing at a time when there is inadequate supply of rental accommodation will drive up rental prices further making it increasingly difficult for first home buyers to save a deposit.”
In an earlier statement, the HIA’s managing director Shane Goodwin said the current “crisis” is the result of 20 years of poor policy.
“For too long governments have chosen quick fix options to the very long term problem of housing affordability. Australia needs brave and bold policies that go to the heart of the affordability problem,” Mr Goodwin said.
“We need to resume the discussion around tax especially where it cascades applies to land and housing and put an end to upfront taxes that are keeping so many first home buyers out of the market,” he continued, responding to a Grattan Institute report which called for an additional 50,000 properties to be built annually for the next decade, among other policy initiatives.
“We need to get serious about planning reform, these things are the keys to solving housing affordability which have largely been overlooked by state and federal governments.”
According to a Real Estate Institute of Australia (REIA) and Adelaide Bank report, housing affordability has worsened, with the proportion of the average family income needed to cover the average loan repayment increasing by 1.3 per cent in the December 2017 quarter.
That means the proportion is now 31.6 per cent.
To REIA president Malcolm Gunning, the Grattan Institute report makes sense. However, building an extra 50,000 homes a year is not a simple prospect.
“We need to address this with some urgency and reform the planning and approval process. We need all tiers of government involved and implementing change,” Mr Gunning said.
“REIA believes a first step in this is the appointment of a minister of property services. This would also recognise the importance of the property sector as a driver of economic growth and employment.
“Property investment supported by historically low interest rates has been a significant contributor to growth in the Australian economy since 2013-14 as we transition away from a decade-long reliance on mining.”
Property
NAB predicts sharp slowing of property prices in 2022
The bank has revised its price forecasts for both 2021 and 2022. ...Read more
Property
Mortgage rates to rise as a result of NZ’s unexpected inflation jump
Three-year bond yields have jumped almost 20 basis points after NZ’s largest inflation rise in over a decade. ...Read more
Property
Rental vacancy rates rise in east-coast CBDs
Vacancy rates nationally remained stable during the month of September. ...Read more
Property
A first home buyer with cold feet? Here are your options
Even first home buyers can get cold feet about stepping onto the property ladder. ...Read more
Property
Demand for affordable housing set to rise
New lending rules introduced by APRA could increase the demand for units and townhouses. ...Read more
Property
Victoria launches $500m fund for home buyers
The Victorian state government has launched a new scheme that promises to make life easier for first-time home buyers. ...Read more
Property
Value of housing outstrips $9 trillion
Five, short months after hitting $8 trillion, the total value of residential real estate in Australia has surpassed a new record of $9.1 trillion. ...Read more
Property
Over 50,000 Australians sign up for government home buyer schemes
The federal government has provided an update on its Home Guarantee Scheme for first home buyers and single parents. ...Read more
How the post-lockdown period will influence property, what the soaring NFT market means, and defining financial wellness
Listen now
APRA’s mortgage crackdown, the power of DeFi and last-minute tax tips
Listen now
What to expect as the end of lockdown looms? Will the Stage 2 tax cuts boost your tax return? Where should investors be looking as the economy reopens?
Listen now
Could property prices inflate by another 20%? What’s happening in recent dividend announcements? Did your fund fail the YFYS test?
Listen now
Property
NAB predicts sharp slowing of property prices in 2022
The bank has revised its price forecasts for both 2021 and 2022. ...Read more
Property
Mortgage rates to rise as a result of NZ’s unexpected inflation jump
Three-year bond yields have jumped almost 20 basis points after NZ’s largest inflation rise in over a decade. ...Read more
Property
Rental vacancy rates rise in east-coast CBDs
Vacancy rates nationally remained stable during the month of September. ...Read more
Property
A first home buyer with cold feet? Here are your options
Even first home buyers can get cold feet about stepping onto the property ladder. ...Read more
Property
Demand for affordable housing set to rise
New lending rules introduced by APRA could increase the demand for units and townhouses. ...Read more
Property
Victoria launches $500m fund for home buyers
The Victorian state government has launched a new scheme that promises to make life easier for first-time home buyers. ...Read more
Property
Value of housing outstrips $9 trillion
Five, short months after hitting $8 trillion, the total value of residential real estate in Australia has surpassed a new record of $9.1 trillion. ...Read more
Property
Over 50,000 Australians sign up for government home buyer schemes
The federal government has provided an update on its Home Guarantee Scheme for first home buyers and single parents. ...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
