Invest
Tesla: Part of disruptor ‘cluster bomb’?
Elon Musk’s baby could be a toxic investment, a funds management firm has warned, describing Tesla and its “overhyped disruptor” ilk as a potential “cluster bomb”.
Tesla: Part of disruptor ‘cluster bomb’?
Elon Musk’s baby could be a toxic investment, a funds management firm has warned, describing Tesla and its “overhyped disruptor” ilk as a potential “cluster bomb”.
Speaking in Sydney this week, Antipodes Partners chief investment officer Jacob Mitchell said the firm was shorting Tesla because it sees a “cluster of opportunities in the overhyped disruptor cluster”.
Mr Mitchell said the current investment zeitgeist is to believe that companies growing now will continue growing, “So why fight it?”
“Maybe we've been foolish fighting it but maybe long term we'll get the payoff in being a bit more independent in our approach to these companies,” he said.
To Mr Mitchell, Tesla’s early successes have been extrapolated thanks to its charismatic leader, favourable early winds and the boon of an ex-Toyota production line.
“I think now though, the decision to move into storage batteries and the decision to move into a mass market vehicle we struggle with because you're going into a highly commoditised segment where, for all sorts of reasons, people really [are] going into price sensitive buys,” he said.
Mr Mitchell argued that Tesla’s strength doesn’t lie in production scale and should be cautious of attempting too many things at once.
“Internalising battery production is a pretty brave thing to do, it requires a lot of capital and they need to be able to invest that capital in, arguably, areas of competitive advantage, which is the assembly design,” he said.
Continuing, Mr Mitchell said original equipment manufacturer companies (OEMs) like Tesla are increasingly becoming design and assembly businesses with finance arms attached.
The OEM industry is also very out of favour.
“I don't think it's out of favour because people think Tesla's going to disrupt the incumbents, I think it's out of favour because investors are worried about where we are in the cycle, obviously trade issues are weighing on performance in the short term, potentially just de-rating it on the back of the fact that it's pretty competitive,” he said.
“But this is the industry that Tesla is interested in, so if the incumbents are worth very little, why should the upstart that's carrying a lot of execution risk – why should it be underrated?”
Nevertheless, Mr Mitchell conceded the difficulty of arguing a large part of the sector was wrong, especially given the current environment where disruption is celebrated.
“The risk here is that a big company feels quite threatened and decides that they must own Tesla and we think that's a very low probability event, but not a zero probability event.”
RELATED ARTICLES
Property
Twice the demand: the case study behind Melbourne’s first‑home buyer surge
Melbourne has quietly engineered one of Australia’s most consequential housing turnarounds, with first‑home buyer demand running at roughly double the national pace and four of the top five buyer ...Read more
Property
First‑home buyers now anchor Australia’s mortgage growth — but the risk maths is changing
Great Southern Bank’s revelation that nearly one in three of its new mortgages went to first‑home buyers is not an outlier. It is the leading edge of a broader market realignment powered by government ...Read more
Property
Home guarantee scheme shake-up challenges Australia’s housing market players
From 1 October 2025, the expanded Home Guarantee Scheme (HGS) materially widens what first-home buyers can purchase and where. By sharply lifting price caps and relaxing eligibility settings, the ...Read more
Property
GSB’s first‑home buyer play: turning policy tailwinds into market share
Great Southern Bank’s latest results show that nearly one in three of its new mortgages now go to first‑home buyers—evidence of a fast‑moving market reshaped by government guarantees, easing rates and ...Read more
Property
Why investors are fleeing and renters are scrambling in Australia's housing maze
Australia’s rental market is tightening even as individual landlords sell down. New data points to a multi‑year investor retreat tied to higher holding costs and regulatory uncertainty, while prices ...Read more
Property
Australia's 5% deposit guarantee: Unlocking gains while balancing risks in the market share race
Can a bigger government guarantee fix housing access without fuelling prices? Australia is about to find out. The Albanese government’s expanded 5% deposit pathway aims to help 70,000 buyers, remove ...Read more
Property
Australia's bold move the 5% deposit scheme shaking up the housing market
Can a government guarantee replace lenders mortgage insurance without inflating prices or risk? Canberra’s accelerated 5% deposit scheme is a bold demand-side nudge in a supply‑constrained marketRead more
Property
When rates drop but stress sticks: exploring Australia's mortgage arrears dilemma
Headline numbers suggest arrears ease as rates come down. The reality in Australia is messier: broad measures dipped into mid‑2025, yet severe delinquencies and non‑bank portfolios remain under ...Read more
Property
Twice the demand: the case study behind Melbourne’s first‑home buyer surge
Melbourne has quietly engineered one of Australia’s most consequential housing turnarounds, with first‑home buyer demand running at roughly double the national pace and four of the top five buyer ...Read more
Property
First‑home buyers now anchor Australia’s mortgage growth — but the risk maths is changing
Great Southern Bank’s revelation that nearly one in three of its new mortgages went to first‑home buyers is not an outlier. It is the leading edge of a broader market realignment powered by government ...Read more
Property
Home guarantee scheme shake-up challenges Australia’s housing market players
From 1 October 2025, the expanded Home Guarantee Scheme (HGS) materially widens what first-home buyers can purchase and where. By sharply lifting price caps and relaxing eligibility settings, the ...Read more
Property
GSB’s first‑home buyer play: turning policy tailwinds into market share
Great Southern Bank’s latest results show that nearly one in three of its new mortgages now go to first‑home buyers—evidence of a fast‑moving market reshaped by government guarantees, easing rates and ...Read more
Property
Why investors are fleeing and renters are scrambling in Australia's housing maze
Australia’s rental market is tightening even as individual landlords sell down. New data points to a multi‑year investor retreat tied to higher holding costs and regulatory uncertainty, while prices ...Read more
Property
Australia's 5% deposit guarantee: Unlocking gains while balancing risks in the market share race
Can a bigger government guarantee fix housing access without fuelling prices? Australia is about to find out. The Albanese government’s expanded 5% deposit pathway aims to help 70,000 buyers, remove ...Read more
Property
Australia's bold move the 5% deposit scheme shaking up the housing market
Can a government guarantee replace lenders mortgage insurance without inflating prices or risk? Canberra’s accelerated 5% deposit scheme is a bold demand-side nudge in a supply‑constrained marketRead more
Property
When rates drop but stress sticks: exploring Australia's mortgage arrears dilemma
Headline numbers suggest arrears ease as rates come down. The reality in Australia is messier: broad measures dipped into mid‑2025, yet severe delinquencies and non‑bank portfolios remain under ...Read more
