Most read
Pros and cons: Working in the gig economy...
Pros and cons: Working in the gig economy...
Latest Podcast
Is the market overheating; should ETFs take your fancy, and what’s happening t...
Is the market overheating; should ETFs take your fancy, and what’s happening t...
Resources
There is $17.5 billion in lost and unclaimed super across ...
There is $17.5 billion in lost and unclaimed super across ...
Invest
Negative gearing: politics of envy or of pain?
Less than 3 per cent of properties are suitable and affordable for single minimum-wage workers, but cutting negative gearing won’t address this challenge, a housing group has said.
Negative gearing: politics of envy or of pain?
Less than 3 per cent of properties are suitable and affordable for single minimum-wage workers, but cutting negative gearing won’t address this challenge, a housing group has said.
Anglicare’s latest Rental Affordability Snapshot has found that for single Australian workers on the minimum wage, just 2.90 per cent of the property market is affordable and appropriate.
A childless couple on the age pension will find 4.43 per cent of listings are affordable and appropriate, but a single person on the age pension can realistically access only 1.24 per cent.
For a single Australian who is older than 18 and on the Newstart Allowance the picture gets worse. Less than 0.01 per cent of properties are affordable and appropriate, down from 0.04 per cent the year before.
Overall, 6 per cent of unique properties were considered affordable and appropriate for households receiving government income support payments.
The report arrives at the same time as the 2015-16 taxation statistics which reveal that the number of Australian property investors increased by 45,867 from 2014-15.
However, going back to the 2012-13 statistics reveals that the number of property investors with five or more properties has grown by 13 per cent, more than triple the rate of growth in investors with just one investment property.
Pointing these numbers out, shadow treasurer Chris Bowen said: “Australia’s extremely generous property tax concession regime sees over 38,000 investors who own at least five properties (over 200,000 properties).
“The new data from the Tax Office again draws out the problems with the current tax concessions on housing – an investor buying their 5th, 6th or 7th property gets more assistance than a first home buyer trying to get into the market.”
He said levelling out the playing field for first home buyers and investors would help address housing affordability.
However, the Housing Industry Association (HIA) has a different view.
Responding to the Tax Statistics, and reports that nearly two-thirds of property investors have an average income of less than $80,000, principal economist at HIA Tim Reardon said: “Further restrictions on negative gearing will lower Australian living standards and increase the cost of renting a home.
“Changes to negative gearing would adversely impact on the housing market, exacerbating the current undersupply of housing and further reduce the efficiency of the housing market.”
He continued, arguing that pushing investors out of the housing market could force the price of renting up, as nearly 25 per cent of rental stock is provided by private investors.
The HIA numbers are based on research conducted for the HIA by The Centre for International Economics (CIE).
“We cannot solve the affordability challenge by increasing the tax on housing or by further restricting those that invest in housing,” Mr Reardon added.
“The solution to housing affordability lies in less tax and less government involvement in housing than in additional constraints on investors.”
His sentiments aligned with those of Treasurer Scott Morrison who argued last week that reforms to negative gearing would prove damaging to the economy.
“You go and put major tax system shocks into the housing market, for parts of our tax system for the housing market that have been around for a century, if you think that… this will have no real impact on the housing markets in Australia, then they [Labor] are more stupid than I thought,” he said.
“This is dangerous policy and it is driven by envy, it is not driven by economics.
Nevertheless, the Anglicare report called for the government to wind back negative gearing and redirect the funds saved into public and community housing.
“Australia’s current housing tax concessions – negative gearing and capital gains tax exemption – favour the wealthiest and encourage property investors, at the expense of people trying to buy or rent a home.
“Anglicare Australia’s recent report, The Cost of Privilege, showed that negative gearing and capital gains tax concessions cost the federal budget a staggering $14.85 billion per year, and overwhelmingly favour the richest.”
While the HIA responded to the fact that nearly two-thirds of property investors were on taxable incomes of less than $80,000, it should be noted that 79 per cent of all Australians are on incomes of less than $80,000.
The argument that negative gearing is used by middle-Australia is a favourite of Mr Morrison, who noted in 2016 that two thirds of negative gearers were on taxable incomes of less than $80,000. In the same comment, he said he always understood the “vast majority of Australians who use negative gearing — they are modest income earning Australians, nurses, teachers, police”.
According to a fact-check performed by the Australian Broadcasting Corporation at the time, this is a “selective” claim given that, at that time, the vast majority (82 per cent) of taxpayers themselves fall into that bracket.
Property
FHB surge as ‘it’s now cheaper to buy than rent’
Record-low interest rates mean that it is now cheaper to buy than rent, with first home buyers taking advantage, doubling their participation in the market, a big four bank CEO has said. ...Read more
Property
New home sales continue to soar in March
A strong level of building activity is expected in 2021 and 2022, given a strong spike in home sales during the year to March. ...Read more
Property
HomeBuilder extension announced
One of the government’s most successful schemes, HomeBuilder, has been extended, bringing the total level of expected government support for the construction sector to $2.5 billion. ...Read more
Property
Policy failures see houses become unattainable for young Australians, minister says
Australia’s booming house prices are the result of the government’s failed policies, with the younger generation now unable to afford what their parents could, a minister has said. ...Read more
Property
House prices to grow by 25% over 3 years
New research is predicting a large gain in property prices of around 25 per cent through to the end of 2023, driven mainly by low interest rates. ...Read more
Property
Strict cap on short-term rentals delayed following criticism
Following widespread criticism from councils and online rental companies, the introduction of NSW’s planned holiday rental code of conduct has been pushed back by three months. ...Read more
Property
Melbourne becomes Australia’s 2nd most affordable rental market
While most capital cities saw house rents soar to new record highs over the first quarter of 2021, Melbourne continued to lag behind – becoming the second most affordable capital city to rent in Aus...Read more
Property
Why home buyers are now more open to high-priced properties
Buyers are more likely to spend more to secure a property as their preferences shift towards bigger spaces with higher price tags, recent data has shown. ...Read more
Is the market overheating; should ETFs take your fancy, and what’s happening to the low and middle income tax offset?
Listen now
Home values up 30% (or are they); NFTs taking the world by storm, and why Keating thinks Aussies will be ‘poor’ in retirement
Listen now
Raging floods, the tech stock bubble and the ongoing SG debate
Listen now
Meet the Manager with Trilogy’s Philip Ryan: RBA rates and property price growth
Listen now
Property
FHB surge as ‘it’s now cheaper to buy than rent’
Record-low interest rates mean that it is now cheaper to buy than rent, with first home buyers taking advantage, doubling their participation in the market, a big four bank CEO has said. ...Read more
Property
New home sales continue to soar in March
A strong level of building activity is expected in 2021 and 2022, given a strong spike in home sales during the year to March. ...Read more
Property
HomeBuilder extension announced
One of the government’s most successful schemes, HomeBuilder, has been extended, bringing the total level of expected government support for the construction sector to $2.5 billion. ...Read more
Property
Policy failures see houses become unattainable for young Australians, minister says
Australia’s booming house prices are the result of the government’s failed policies, with the younger generation now unable to afford what their parents could, a minister has said. ...Read more
Property
House prices to grow by 25% over 3 years
New research is predicting a large gain in property prices of around 25 per cent through to the end of 2023, driven mainly by low interest rates. ...Read more
Property
Strict cap on short-term rentals delayed following criticism
Following widespread criticism from councils and online rental companies, the introduction of NSW’s planned holiday rental code of conduct has been pushed back by three months. ...Read more
Property
Melbourne becomes Australia’s 2nd most affordable rental market
While most capital cities saw house rents soar to new record highs over the first quarter of 2021, Melbourne continued to lag behind – becoming the second most affordable capital city to rent in Aus...Read more
Property
Why home buyers are now more open to high-priced properties
Buyers are more likely to spend more to secure a property as their preferences shift towards bigger spaces with higher price tags, recent data has shown. ...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
