Invest
Real estate mogul enters negative gearing fray
The chairman of a major Australian real estate group has said all taxpayers will be impacted if “radical” negative gearing changes cause property prices to fall.
Real estate mogul enters negative gearing fray
The chairman of a major Australian real estate group has said all taxpayers will be impacted if “radical” negative gearing changes cause property prices to fall.
Ray White chairman, Brian White is the latest to enter the negative gearing debate, issuing a firm warning on Tuesday (9 January) that changes to negative gearing policy could cause “more harm than good”.
His comments follow the revelation on Monday (8 January) that the Turnbull government had received Treasury modelling of the impact of the Labor Party’s proposed plan to limit negative gearing to new homes while cutting capital gains concessions from 50 to 25 per cent.
The modelling found that the policy would have a “relatively modest” impact on prices over time.
Shadow treasurer Chris Bowen said the documents, released following a Freedom of Information request lodged by the ABC, proved that the government had spread “little more than outright lies” about the policy’s potential impact, referencing Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull’s argument that Labor’s policy was a “sledgehammer”.
Speaking in 2016, Mr Turnbull said: “What Labor is proposing is a huge, reckless shock to the market. This is no fine tuning; this is a sledgehammer they are taking to the property market."
However, Mr White has argued that the documents “further vindicate” the property industry’s stance against any changes to negative gearing.
Mr White said: “Even more important than modelling are historical trends. The only time similar changes to property taxation were previously attempted was under the Hawke government in the mid-80s resulted in a devastating effect that forced the Labor government to reverse their policy a short time later.
“It was the worst time for property owners since the credit crunch of the Whitlam era, with so many Australians significantly affected in the worst possible way.
“The outcome was so bad, Labor themselves had to revert their own decision after just 18 months.”
Continuing, he argued that any changes implemented now would have worse ramifications as the property market is “already softening”.
According to CoreLogic figures, residential property values took a slight 0.3 per cent fall in December last year, with the country experiencing a “clear but gradual” transition towards weaker housing market conditions.
“There’s no telling how a second attempt would play out in a market that’s already softening,” Mr White claimed.
“A stable property market is fundamental to a strong economy. Based on the data we reviewed at the time of the election, more than 10 per cent of all taxpayers from all walks of life use negative gearing but when property prices fall, it also affects the 67 per cent of Australians who own their own home.”
The redacted documents noted that negative gearing benefits families with high incomes, with only 5.2 per cent of negative gearing tax benefits going to people earning incomes in the bottom 20 per cent. At the same time, 52.6 per cent of the tax benefit flows through to people earning incomes in the top 20 per cent.
Treasury’s modelling further noted that the capital gains tax discount “overwhelmingly benefits” high income families. Nearly three-quarters of the tax savings benefited families with incomes in the top 10 per cent.
Mr White also argued that a hit to property prices could negatively impact the 18 million Australians whose savings are connected to property via their super funds.
“What is clear is that implementing radical policies in this arena doesn’t work and causes more harm than good,” Mr White concluded.
“We have to learn from previous mistakes and that is the essence of good policy.”
RELATED ARTICLES
Property
Hidden cost, higher prices: Why a council fee fight matters for Australia’s housing pipeline
A dispute between the Housing Industry Association and Goulburn Mulwaree Council over development cost estimates is more than a local skirmish—it spotlights a systemic pricing lever that can compound ...Read more
Property
Why Aussie homes are turning into stepping stones for the new generation
A new cohort of buyers is treating their first property as a launchpad, not a destination—and the mortgage industry is pivoting in lockstep. Read more
Property
Rate cuts ignite an upsizing wave: how to win the next phase of Australia’s housing cycle
Cheaper money is reviving borrowing capacity and confidence, and upsizers are back in force — most visibly at auctions where clearance rates have lifted to yearly highs. The ripple effects extend ...Read more
Property
Rate anxiety fades, affordability bites: What Australia’s property market shift means for business
Australian buyers are no longer driven primarily by interest rate fears; the binding constraint is affordability. New research shows price pressure, not policy moves, is shaping behaviour—forcing ...Read more
Property
South Australia's first-home buyer boom fuels a frenzy for lenders, builders and retailers
South Australia has quietly become the nation’s most active first‑home buyer market, fuelled by falling rates, generous state incentives and a responsive broker ecosystem. Read more
Property
Melbourne’s turning point: the 2025 playbook for investors—and the 2026 upside
After lagging other capitals, Melbourne is quietly moving off the floor. Prices have logged several consecutive months of growth, rental markets remain tight, and forecasts point to a sharper upswing ...Read more
Property
Brisbane hits the million-dollar mark as growth takes a detour and investors eye new opportunities
Brisbane has crossed the symbolic $1 million median for houses, but the more investable momentum is in units—and the growth curve is flattening. Read more
Property
North platform adds household reporting feature to boost adviser efficiency
AMP's North platform has launched consolidated household reporting across multiple client accounts, helping financial advisers streamline their client review processes. Read more
Property
Hidden cost, higher prices: Why a council fee fight matters for Australia’s housing pipeline
A dispute between the Housing Industry Association and Goulburn Mulwaree Council over development cost estimates is more than a local skirmish—it spotlights a systemic pricing lever that can compound ...Read more
Property
Why Aussie homes are turning into stepping stones for the new generation
A new cohort of buyers is treating their first property as a launchpad, not a destination—and the mortgage industry is pivoting in lockstep. Read more
Property
Rate cuts ignite an upsizing wave: how to win the next phase of Australia’s housing cycle
Cheaper money is reviving borrowing capacity and confidence, and upsizers are back in force — most visibly at auctions where clearance rates have lifted to yearly highs. The ripple effects extend ...Read more
Property
Rate anxiety fades, affordability bites: What Australia’s property market shift means for business
Australian buyers are no longer driven primarily by interest rate fears; the binding constraint is affordability. New research shows price pressure, not policy moves, is shaping behaviour—forcing ...Read more
Property
South Australia's first-home buyer boom fuels a frenzy for lenders, builders and retailers
South Australia has quietly become the nation’s most active first‑home buyer market, fuelled by falling rates, generous state incentives and a responsive broker ecosystem. Read more
Property
Melbourne’s turning point: the 2025 playbook for investors—and the 2026 upside
After lagging other capitals, Melbourne is quietly moving off the floor. Prices have logged several consecutive months of growth, rental markets remain tight, and forecasts point to a sharper upswing ...Read more
Property
Brisbane hits the million-dollar mark as growth takes a detour and investors eye new opportunities
Brisbane has crossed the symbolic $1 million median for houses, but the more investable momentum is in units—and the growth curve is flattening. Read more
Property
North platform adds household reporting feature to boost adviser efficiency
AMP's North platform has launched consolidated household reporting across multiple client accounts, helping financial advisers streamline their client review processes. Read more
