Invest
Lenders’ ‘white-collar crime’ putting investors at risk
An economic analyst has accused Australian lenders of “white-collar” crimes which have placed both property investors and the Australian economy at risk.
Lenders’ ‘white-collar crime’ putting investors at risk
An economic analyst has accused Australian lenders of “white-collar” crimes which have placed both property investors and the Australian economy at risk.
Lindsay David, founder of LF Economics, said in The Big Rort: A Mortgage Market Built on Deceit and Fraud that the way Australian lenders measure borrowers’ ability to repay loans can be problematic for the borrowers themselves.
According to Mr David, many Australian lenders use a combined loan-to-value ratio (LVR), as opposed to an individual LVR.
The approach allows investors to effectively use the unrealised capital in a property they already own as collateral, or a substitute for a cash deposit, against the property for which they require a loan. At the same time, lenders have the ability to report the LVR as being lower than it is, he explained.
“The use of unrealised capital gain (equity) of one property to secure financing to purchase another property in Australia is extreme.”
He continued: “Under these conditions, lenders produce guaranteed, exceptional short-term profits through a four-part strategy: extreme loan growth, high leverage, minimal loss reserves and declining underwriting standards.”
Further, he warned that a “high proportion” of Australia’s historically high household debt will “never be repaid” and argued that the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) and the Australian Securities & Investments Commission (ASIC) were culpable for their lack of regulatory enforcement.
Referring to a number of parliamentary submissions made by LF Economics inquiries into white-collar crime penalties and the banking, insurance and financial services inquiry, Mr David said there is “evidence to suggest the regulators have played a critical role in allowing mortgage control fraud to flourish “even in the face of consumer protection laws”.
Mr David explained that mortgage control fraud is the practice of lenders intentionally defrauding borrowers by lending “far in excess” of borrowers’ ability to service the loan.
He added that the practice had reached “epidemic levels, especially in direct lending to high-risk borrowers and repackaging these loans into seemingly high-quality residential mortgage-backed securities”.
Mr David went on to argue that courtesy of lenders issuing of loans against unrealised capital gains, the Australian housing market had “ballooned” and now resembled a “house of cards”.
Pointing to a lack of regulatory enforcement and a “complete disregard” to the National Consumer Protection Act, Mr David claimed that housing sector participants “have been able to create an expanding house of cards by issuing interest-only loans to owners for the purchase of either an investment property or a new home for their adult children with very little or even no cash deposit.”
RELATED ARTICLES
Property
Rents are rewriting the inflation playbook: what record‑low vacancies mean for Australian business
Australia’s rental market is so tight that housing costs are now a primary transmission channel for inflation and interest rates. This isn’t just a property story; it’s a business risk story—affecting ...Read more
Property
Off-market real estate is going mainstream — and changing the rules of dealmaking
With public listings tight and sales still climbing, Australia’s investors are shifting to off-market channels that reward speed, networks and data advantage. The playbook is closer to private equity ...Read more
Property
Australia’s rental squeeze is now a business problem: inflation, capacity and the new growth calculus
Record-low rental vacancies are no longer just a social headline – they’re reshaping cost structures, wage dynamics and capital allocation across corporate Australia. With economists warning of a ...Read more
Property
Rents Are Repricing Australia Inc: What record‑low vacancies mean for inflation, talent and strategy
Australia’s rental market has slipped into a vacancy desert, and it’s not just tenants feeling the heat. Persistently tight supply is pushing up rents, embedding services inflation and complicating ...Read more
Property
Young buyers poised for a comeback as 5% First Home Guarantee takes effect
In a move set to reshape the Australian property landscape, the government’s revamped First Home Guarantee is poised to open the doors of homeownership to a new generation of young AustraliansRead more
Property
AFG Securities waives settlement fees for first-home buyers, signalling strategic shift
In a strategic move aimed at easing the financial burden on first-home buyers, AFG Securities has announced the elimination of settlement fees on select loans, potentially saving customers up to $699Read more
Property
From trust woes to wealth: Australian agencies' secret to boosting prices
In Australia’s residential market, trust is no longer a nice-to-have—it’s a pricing variable. Persistent distrust of real estate agents is depressing vendor outcomes and inviting regulatory heat, but ...Read more
Property
Reality check for first home buyers: Affordable suburbs with 5% deposit
In a significant development for Australian first home buyers, a new property search tool from Aussie Home Loans is set to transform the way prospective homeowners approach the market. As the Federal ...Read more
Property
Rents are rewriting the inflation playbook: what record‑low vacancies mean for Australian business
Australia’s rental market is so tight that housing costs are now a primary transmission channel for inflation and interest rates. This isn’t just a property story; it’s a business risk story—affecting ...Read more
Property
Off-market real estate is going mainstream — and changing the rules of dealmaking
With public listings tight and sales still climbing, Australia’s investors are shifting to off-market channels that reward speed, networks and data advantage. The playbook is closer to private equity ...Read more
Property
Australia’s rental squeeze is now a business problem: inflation, capacity and the new growth calculus
Record-low rental vacancies are no longer just a social headline – they’re reshaping cost structures, wage dynamics and capital allocation across corporate Australia. With economists warning of a ...Read more
Property
Rents Are Repricing Australia Inc: What record‑low vacancies mean for inflation, talent and strategy
Australia’s rental market has slipped into a vacancy desert, and it’s not just tenants feeling the heat. Persistently tight supply is pushing up rents, embedding services inflation and complicating ...Read more
Property
Young buyers poised for a comeback as 5% First Home Guarantee takes effect
In a move set to reshape the Australian property landscape, the government’s revamped First Home Guarantee is poised to open the doors of homeownership to a new generation of young AustraliansRead more
Property
AFG Securities waives settlement fees for first-home buyers, signalling strategic shift
In a strategic move aimed at easing the financial burden on first-home buyers, AFG Securities has announced the elimination of settlement fees on select loans, potentially saving customers up to $699Read more
Property
From trust woes to wealth: Australian agencies' secret to boosting prices
In Australia’s residential market, trust is no longer a nice-to-have—it’s a pricing variable. Persistent distrust of real estate agents is depressing vendor outcomes and inviting regulatory heat, but ...Read more
Property
Reality check for first home buyers: Affordable suburbs with 5% deposit
In a significant development for Australian first home buyers, a new property search tool from Aussie Home Loans is set to transform the way prospective homeowners approach the market. As the Federal ...Read more
