Invest
Have investors lost sight of the ‘real world’?
An overreliance on modern portfolio theory could be leading Aussie investors to failure, a portfolio manager has warned, calling for more awareness of, and appreciation for, the underlying companies.
Have investors lost sight of the ‘real world’?
An overreliance on modern portfolio theory could be leading Aussie investors to failure, a portfolio manager has warned, calling for more awareness of, and appreciation for, the underlying companies.
According to Steven Bleiberg, portfolio manager at New York-based Epoch Investment Partners, modern portfolio theory (MPT) has been a good thing for people’s understanding of investing, but can also hinder those seeking active management.
“It is our contention that over the last 50 years, some investors have become so enamored of the theory that they have lost sight of the real world underlying the theory,” he said.
Mr Bleiberg argued that investors relying on MPT are viewing stocks as collections of factor exposures, rather than businesses and that MPT-reliance has contributed to the belief that a market index is more than a broad measure of the market, but is an optimal portfolio.
“This has led people to believe that it is a positive good to make no effort to judge whether a business is worth owning,” he said.
“We need to remember that in reality individual stocks rise and fall because of the success or failure of the underlying businesses; that the market as a whole rises or falls because of the ability of the average business to generate a premium over its cost of capital; and that not every publicly traded company is a business worth owning.”
Stocks are more than just a set of statistics, Mr Bleiberg reminded investors, and investors who correlate returns with factor exposures also run the risk of reversing cause and effect in how they think about the investing world.
He explained, “Many investment practitioners have become so enamored of this theoretical framework that they reverse cause and effect in the way they think about the world.
“They seem to think that a stock did well because it had exposure to certain factors that did well, as if the factor returns have an independent existence of their own out in the cosmic ether, apart from the success or failure of the underlying companies.”
It’s the performance of the business that results in changing stock prices and theoretical factor returns, Mr Bleiberg said.
“That is, company stock price movements drive factor returns; factor returns don’t drive company stock price movements,” he said.
“Or to put it yet another way, markets don’t reward or punish abstract factors; they reward or punish companies because of how well or poorly their business is doing, and that in turn creates what we end up measuring as ‘factor returns’. But we should never lose sight of the fact that those factor returns are a derivative. They are not the starting point.”
Mr Bleiberg said investors should take care to not become “caught up” in a model and lose sight of real-world investing.
“Successful investing in equities is about identifying companies that create value for their owners by earning high returns on the capital that they take from those owners and invest in their business,” he said.
He concluded, “As helpful as it is to have all of the insights that MPT offers – and it offers many – an investor still has to understand the ‘why’ behind a successful business.”
Property
Aussies swap housemates for home ownership
The number of younger Australians looking to enter the property market in the next five years has doubled, as COVID-19 restrictions sees home ownership goals increase, according to research released ...Read more
Property
Falling loan deferrals prove market recovery: REIA
The reduction in loan deferral defies doom and gloom forecasts in the property market, the Real Estate Industry of Australia has said. ...Read more
Property
Why are expats returning to property market?
Expats are returning to Australia in droves, eager to put their money into safe investments. ...Read more
Property
Stamp duty to be phased out under new proposal
The NSW government has stated that it could phase out inefficient taxes such as stamp duty as it looks to recover from the COVID-19 pandemic. ...Read more
Property
Melbourne rents continue to decline
While most capital cities recorded increases in asking rents, Melbourne continued to see declines in both houses and units, according to latest data from SQM Research. ...Read more
Property
Why investors should focus on the next 1-5 years
Investors are being urged to look beyond their own backyards into opportunities over the next one to five years. ...Read more
Property
Distressed sales fall to pre-pandemic levels
Urgent property sales have dropped back to pre-pandemic levels in most cities – proof of Australia’s continuous recovery from the effects of the COVID-19 outbreak. ...Read more
Property
Top tips for managing your own property portfolio
Managing investment properties can feel very much like rolling a dice, you can never be quite sure what you’re going to encounter and, in most cases, you possess minimal control over what happens ne...Read more
Property
Aussies swap housemates for home ownership
The number of younger Australians looking to enter the property market in the next five years has doubled, as COVID-19 restrictions sees home ownership goals increase, according to research released ...Read more
Property
Falling loan deferrals prove market recovery: REIA
The reduction in loan deferral defies doom and gloom forecasts in the property market, the Real Estate Industry of Australia has said. ...Read more
Property
Why are expats returning to property market?
Expats are returning to Australia in droves, eager to put their money into safe investments. ...Read more
Property
Stamp duty to be phased out under new proposal
The NSW government has stated that it could phase out inefficient taxes such as stamp duty as it looks to recover from the COVID-19 pandemic. ...Read more
Property
Melbourne rents continue to decline
While most capital cities recorded increases in asking rents, Melbourne continued to see declines in both houses and units, according to latest data from SQM Research. ...Read more
Property
Why investors should focus on the next 1-5 years
Investors are being urged to look beyond their own backyards into opportunities over the next one to five years. ...Read more
Property
Distressed sales fall to pre-pandemic levels
Urgent property sales have dropped back to pre-pandemic levels in most cities – proof of Australia’s continuous recovery from the effects of the COVID-19 outbreak. ...Read more
Property
Top tips for managing your own property portfolio
Managing investment properties can feel very much like rolling a dice, you can never be quite sure what you’re going to encounter and, in most cases, you possess minimal control over what happens ne...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
