Invest
Curtailing investor discounts a housing affordability solution, but it needs to be gradual
Invest
Curtailing investor discounts a housing affordability solution, but it needs to be gradual
Housing affordability has been hindered by the influence of “entrenched commercial interests”, but gradual reductions in investor discounts could chip away at the issue while protecting “mum and dad” investors.
Curtailing investor discounts a housing affordability solution, but it needs to be gradual
Housing affordability has been hindered by the influence of “entrenched commercial interests”, but gradual reductions in investor discounts could chip away at the issue while protecting “mum and dad” investors.
That’s according to the Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute’s (AHURI) latest report, Pathways to housing tax reform, which proposed a gradual winding-down in capital gains tax discounts’ generosity over a decade, from 50 per cent to 30 per cent, and the same for negative gearing provisions.
It proposed an initial $20,000 cap on housing-related tax deductions, which would then be reduced by about $1,500 every year until it reached $5,000. Revenue raised from these reforms would be funnelled into social and affordable housing.
Additionally, it said the family home should eventually be reflected in the age pension asset test. However, it acknowledged that any changes would need to come with a strong deferral scheme to allow asset rich and income poor pensioners access to the age pension, while ageing in place at home.
The report was the final piece in an inquiry that aims to produce “meaningful long-term political pathways” to a more efficient, sustainable and equitable housing tax policy.
The researchers, from the University of Tasmania, University of New South Wales, University of Sydney and Curtin University, said such a policy was necessary, as “entrenched commercial interests” had influenced the political process to the point where consensus on the need for change had been drowned out.
They also said failures to improve tax policy had exacerbated intergenerational inequality, reduced mobility and inflated housing prices.
The researchers said this reduction, which would occur over the decade, would have a minimal impact on “mum and dad” investors while saving the government $1.7 billion from the $3.04 billion negative gearing deductions’ annual price tag.
“One of our key findings is that gradually reducing the generosity of capital gains tax and negative gearing provisions over a decade-long timeframe would result in only a modest impact on the after-tax return from housing investments for most ‘mum and dad’ investors, with the exact figures depending on wage income, interest rates and capital growth,” lead researcher Professor Richard Eccleston from the University of Tasmania said.
AHURI’s modelling suggested that in the first year, beginning to reduce the discounts’ generosity by implementing a $20,000 cap would see only 6.3 per cent of property investors – 1.1 per cent of taxpayers – affected.
Even a decade later, 28.5 per cent of high income property investors would be paying more tax but most “mum and dad” property investors would experience no difference in the tax they pay.
The researchers found a broad-based property tax to be “more efficient and fairer” than stamp duty, and proposed a graduated process in which stamp duty evolves over three-five years to increase for investors holding high value properties, before shifting to a broad-based property tax over a longer term five-20 year period.
Join the nestegg community
We Translate Complicated Financial Jargon Into Easy-To-Understand Information For Australians
Your email address will be shared with nestegg and subject to our Privacy Policy
Join The Nest Egg community
We Translate Complicated Financial Jargon Into Easy-To-Understand Information For Australians
Your email address will be shared with nestegg and subject to our Privacy Policy
HomeBuilder prediction: 8 suburbs set to boom
Hot Property: Biggest headlines from the week that was
Property market dips for second straight month
COVID-induced job losses ‘less likely’ to hit borrowers
Investors need structured, technology-based approach to data to succeed
Hot Property: Biggest headlines from the week that was
Depreciation deductions ‘never needed more’ for landlords
16 types of tax deductions to claim on your investment property
Property
HomeBuilder prediction: 8 suburbs set to boom
There are eight areas that “are about to blow up”, thanks to the advent of the federal government’s HomeBuilder grant, according to a property professional. ...Read more
Property
Hot Property: Biggest headlines from the week that was
It’s a new financial year and some Victorian areas have re-entered stage 3 restrictions due to COVID-19: Here are the biggest property stories from this week. ...Read more
Property
Property market dips for second straight month
Falls in national house prices accelerated over the month of June, with the September cliff still looming, new research has shown. ...Read more
Property
COVID-induced job losses ‘less likely’ to hit borrowers
Government support and a banking system that is allowing members to defer loan repayments has led to a milder than expected mortgage delinquency rate, which could offset the impact of job losses on th...Read more
Property
Investors need structured, technology-based approach to data to succeed
Investors who want to be in the top decimal of property investors are being advised to focus on big data as a means to differentiate themselves from the rest of the group. ...Read more
Property
Hot Property: Biggest headlines from the week that was
Businesses are beginning their rebound post-COVID-19 despite Victoria’s second wave of infections, while brokers have gotten a glimpse of what their new best interests duty to consumers will look li...Read more
Property
Depreciation deductions ‘never needed more’ for landlords
Australia’s largest provider of tax depreciation schedules has flagged how lucrative tax benefits will provide a financial boost for landlords who have been struggling amid the coronavirus pandemic....Read more
Property
16 types of tax deductions to claim on your investment property
There are several big-ticket items you should be claiming on your investment property this tax time – have you accounted for them all? ...Read more
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.