Invest
Property crackdown slammed as ineffectual ‘ethnic profiling’
Despite an impressive headline figure of $100 million, the government’s much-touted crackdown on foreign property buyers will have ‘no impact’ on housing markets, says a property market expert.
Property crackdown slammed as ineffectual ‘ethnic profiling’
Despite an impressive headline figure of $100 million, the government’s much-touted crackdown on foreign property buyers will have ‘no impact’ on housing markets, says a property market expert.
Earlier this week, Treasurer Scott Morrison announced that the government’s campaign to force foreign buyers to sell illegally acquired real estate has exceeded $100 million in sales.
However, Domain chief economist Andrew Wilson told nestegg.com.au the crackdown will have zero impact on housing markets.
“Clearly, this won't have any impact on housing markets. The numbers just aren't there and even though the $100 million headline might sound impressive, that really only amounts to the equivalent of maybe 50 houses in Sydney, in a transaction environment of hundreds of thousands of sales,” Mr Wilson said.
“As an aggregated measure, it’s not going to have an impact on markets and generally speaking these numbers are small, they were always likely to be small and these foreign buyers weren’t really having an impact on the market at all.”
The government’s latest addition of 15 new forced sales in Victoria and Queensland pushed the campaign’s running total to 61 properties, with a combined value of $107 million.
The total figure is heavily inflated by the inclusion of a $39 million Point Piper mansion, along with several other multimillion-dollar sales.
The highest ten forced property sales account for more than $78 million of that total, leaving 51 properties to round out the final $29 million.
The clampdown, which has been targeting foreign nationals who purchased property without Foreign Investment Review Board (FIRB) approval, is a product of the long-running debate that foreign property buyers, and particularly Chinese buyers, have allegedly been driving up property prices.
“These changes to the regulations came from the strong narrative last year surrounding perceptions that foreign buyers were impacting house prices and creating some imbalances in the market. It was a bit of the blame game,” Mr Wilson said.
“Foreign buyers aren’t an issue at all and they never really were. In hot markets, and particularly Sydney where we had extraordinary clearance rates in 2015 and into 2016, unfortunately we moved into ethnic profiling.”
Implicated in the forced sales were foreign nationals from the UK, Canada, US, India, Malaysia, China and Germany.
Aside from forced sales, the government also issued 388 penalty notices to foreign nationals found to be in breach of either FIRB approval or conditions of a previously approved application.
However, despite claims the crackdown made no difference to the Australian property market, it may still have some upside.
“It’s a positive outcome that the government did tighten regulations and to some degree at least it helped moderate that type of debate we were having where now there isn’t that strong narrative anymore of Chinese buyers being blamed for high prices,” Mr Wilson said.
“It’s also positive that they located some non-conformances which is what the whole process was for.”
Property
Millennials believe first home buyers need more support
Australia’s up-and-comers in the housing market say more needs to be done to slow rising house prices. ...Read more
Property
3 in 4 borrowers in trouble are in lockdown: ANZ
Despite offering support, ANZ said freezing home loan repayments will be the last resort, as three in four requests for support stem from NSW. ...Read more
Property
RBA gives APRA’s use of macro tools a tick of approval
Ahead of an expected move to impose tougher lending rules on the banks, the Reserve Bank has looked into previous attempts by APRA to cool the housing market. ...Read more
Property
Federal incentives are driving more first home buyers into the market
While property prices continue to grow, new research suggests that the government’s current crop of first home buyer incentives is having an impact on this segment of the market. ...Read more
Property
Why it now costs 130% more to service a mortgage than 3 decades ago
The lifetime cost of owning a home has increased by over 130 per cent in just three decades, new research has revealed. ...Read more
Property
Using the 30/30/3 rule for home buying during uncertain times
Thinking of buying a home? Uncertain economic times may have you double guessing your purchase, but the 30/30/3 rule can help you make this a reality. ...Read more
Property
Rental yields reach decade high, but not all markets move at the same pace
Changing consumer preferences towards lifestyle destinations and a lack of supply have led to record national price growth, albeit price fluctuations vary region-to-region, fresh figures show. ...Read more
Property
What younger Australians are getting wrong about home loans
As young Australians look to fight the odds and take their first step onto the property ladder, more and more are making easy mistakes. ...Read more
The Olympic effect on property and equity investors; COVID-19 Disaster Payments and super
Listen now
Do lockdowns boost property prices? Are short-sellers levelling the playing field? Did you lodge your tax returns early?
Listen now
Will lockdowns halt the housing boom? Is the metaverse taking over? And the cons of lodging your tax returns early
Listen now
Are you being priced out of the market? Have you got the Tuesday blues? And are you ready for the upcoming super changes?
Listen now
Property
Millennials believe first home buyers need more support
Australia’s up-and-comers in the housing market say more needs to be done to slow rising house prices. ...Read more
Property
3 in 4 borrowers in trouble are in lockdown: ANZ
Despite offering support, ANZ said freezing home loan repayments will be the last resort, as three in four requests for support stem from NSW. ...Read more
Property
RBA gives APRA’s use of macro tools a tick of approval
Ahead of an expected move to impose tougher lending rules on the banks, the Reserve Bank has looked into previous attempts by APRA to cool the housing market. ...Read more
Property
Federal incentives are driving more first home buyers into the market
While property prices continue to grow, new research suggests that the government’s current crop of first home buyer incentives is having an impact on this segment of the market. ...Read more
Property
Why it now costs 130% more to service a mortgage than 3 decades ago
The lifetime cost of owning a home has increased by over 130 per cent in just three decades, new research has revealed. ...Read more
Property
Using the 30/30/3 rule for home buying during uncertain times
Thinking of buying a home? Uncertain economic times may have you double guessing your purchase, but the 30/30/3 rule can help you make this a reality. ...Read more
Property
Rental yields reach decade high, but not all markets move at the same pace
Changing consumer preferences towards lifestyle destinations and a lack of supply have led to record national price growth, albeit price fluctuations vary region-to-region, fresh figures show. ...Read more
Property
What younger Australians are getting wrong about home loans
As young Australians look to fight the odds and take their first step onto the property ladder, more and more are making easy mistakes. ...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
