Invest
3 costly mistakes property investors make
Depreciation of investment properties can be confusing at the best of times. Here are some of the mistakes you should be avoiding as you file your tax return for this financial year.
3 costly mistakes property investors make
Depreciation of investment properties can be confusing at the best of times. Here are some of the mistakes you should be avoiding as you file your tax return for this financial year.
Property investors can claim sizeable deductions for the natural wear and tear that takes place in a building – this is property depreciation.
But BMT Tax Depreciation’s Bradley Beer has noted that many investors fail to engage a specialist quantity surveyor for such purposes and are missing out on claiming valuable dollars back at tax time as a result.
He revealed the three most common depreciation mistakes he encounters:
- Getting the depreciation category wrong
There are two types of depreciation deductions: capital works (Division 43) and plant and equipment (Division 40).

To make things confusing, “it’s not often immediately clear which category an item belongs to, and in some cases an asset can be split between both”, Mr Beer explained.
Capital works relate to the wear and tear of a building’s structure and the items permanently fixed to the property, such as doors and windows. They are typically depreciated at an annual rate of 2.5 per cent over 40 years.
On the other hand, plant and equipment items can be easily removed, which include things like blinds, hot water systems and furniture.
According to Mr Beer, the condition, quality and effective life will determine the allowances available for a plant and equipment asset.
A floating timber floor is one example of how this gets confusing.
“Many investors mistake floating timber flooring as permanently fixed to the building and therefore a capital works deduction when it’s actually removable, making it a plant and equipment deduction,” Mr Beer said.
“This could mean the difference between $250 and over $1,300 in first year deductions.”
A ducted air conditioning system is another example that doesn’t necessarily lend itself to logic.
The unit itself is considered plant and equipment while the ducting for the same unit falls under capital works.
“Claiming an entire ducted air conditioning unit under Division 43 would result in substantially higher but incorrect first year deductions, which would come under ATO scrutiny,” the CEO conceded.
- Assuming depreciation on older properties can’t be claimed
While research has been done that confirms new properties hold the highest depreciation deductions, there are still aspects of depreciation that can be claimed on older properties.
Legislation that came into play in 2017 does mean that the depreciation of second-hand plant and equipment assets can no longer be claimed.
But this does not affect capital works deductions.
According to Mr Beer, capital works deductions make up the bulk of a depreciation claim on an investment property anyway, regardless of whether it’s a new build or not.
“Second-hand property owners can still claim depreciation on all qualifying capital works deductions that, on average, make up 85 to 90 per cent of the total claim. They can also claim all new plant and equipment assets they purchase for the property,” the depreciation expert indicated.
During the 2019-20 financial year, Mr Beer revealed that BMT Tax Depreciation found an average depreciation claim of more than $8,300 for client properties.
- Overlooking deductions
Many depreciation deductions are easily missed by the untrained eye, especially on assets that have been installed by others, the CEO has revealed.
He flagged that substantial renovations where all, or substantially all, of a building is removed or replaced can hold significant deductions – even when completed by a previous owner.
“Some examples of substantial renovations include replacing foundations of the building, walls, floors, the roof or staircases.”
Mr Beer explained that these renovations can hold tens of thousands of dollars in deductions for the new owner.
When an investor purchases a second-hand property immediately after a substantial renovation, the 2017 legislation changes don’t apply, which means the new owner can claim depreciation on all new plant and equipment assets and the capital works.
It’s why Mr Beer is urging investors to contact a specialist quantity surveyor for advice on what deductions are available for their individual circumstances.
About the author
About the author
Property
Trust, technology and triage: what NSW’s ‘name and shame’ signals for real estate governance
NSW’s latest enforcement action on real estate trust accounts isn’t a one-off embarrassment; it’s a stress test of sector governance. With licences suspended and penalties applied, the message is ...Read more
Property
Vacancy is rising, demand is resilient: A case study in defending yield as Australia’s rental cycle rebalances
After a blistering run, Australia’s rental market is loosening at the edges. Vacancy is edging up off historic lows, rent inflation is set to moderate into 2026, yet underlying demand remains ...Read more
Property
Don’t lose the deposit: A case study in stopping real estate payment fraud — and the ROI for doing it
Deposit redirection scams are quietly eroding buyer savings and agency reputations in Australia’s property market. This case study unpacks how a mid-tier real estate group redesigned its settlement ...Read more
Property
The $12m threshold: Why portfolio value, not property count, now defines Australia’s investor elite
The old yardstick of six properties as shorthand for investment success has been overtaken by a harsher reality: in today’s market, elite status is defined by balance-sheet strength, not asset countRead more
Property
From intuition to instrumentation: How a "two-stakeholder" sales playbook lifted close rates and cut cycle times
High-stakes consumer purchases are increasingly joint decisions. When one partner is under-served, deals stall. This case study follows an Australian real estate group that rebuilt its sales motion ...Read more
Property
Selling in 2025: How to spot bad agents fast—and build an ROI-first vendor playbook
In Australia’s property market, choosing the wrong listing agent isn’t just inconvenient—it’s a textbook principal–agent failure that can wipe tens of thousands off your sale outcomeRead more
Property
Selling in 2026: How to de‑risk your agent choice and protect tens of thousands at settlement
Choosing the wrong selling agent isn’t just an inconvenience — it’s a balance‑sheet risk. In a market where digital discovery is concentrated and AI is recasting how listings are priced and promoted, ...Read more
Property
Rate resilience in Australian housing: why scarce supply is overpowering monetary tightening
Australia’s housing market is defying higher borrowing costs because the binding constraint isn’t demand—it’s supply. Brokers report persistent buyer competition and investor repositioning, while ...Read more
Property
Trust, technology and triage: what NSW’s ‘name and shame’ signals for real estate governance
NSW’s latest enforcement action on real estate trust accounts isn’t a one-off embarrassment; it’s a stress test of sector governance. With licences suspended and penalties applied, the message is ...Read more
Property
Vacancy is rising, demand is resilient: A case study in defending yield as Australia’s rental cycle rebalances
After a blistering run, Australia’s rental market is loosening at the edges. Vacancy is edging up off historic lows, rent inflation is set to moderate into 2026, yet underlying demand remains ...Read more
Property
Don’t lose the deposit: A case study in stopping real estate payment fraud — and the ROI for doing it
Deposit redirection scams are quietly eroding buyer savings and agency reputations in Australia’s property market. This case study unpacks how a mid-tier real estate group redesigned its settlement ...Read more
Property
The $12m threshold: Why portfolio value, not property count, now defines Australia’s investor elite
The old yardstick of six properties as shorthand for investment success has been overtaken by a harsher reality: in today’s market, elite status is defined by balance-sheet strength, not asset countRead more
Property
From intuition to instrumentation: How a "two-stakeholder" sales playbook lifted close rates and cut cycle times
High-stakes consumer purchases are increasingly joint decisions. When one partner is under-served, deals stall. This case study follows an Australian real estate group that rebuilt its sales motion ...Read more
Property
Selling in 2025: How to spot bad agents fast—and build an ROI-first vendor playbook
In Australia’s property market, choosing the wrong listing agent isn’t just inconvenient—it’s a textbook principal–agent failure that can wipe tens of thousands off your sale outcomeRead more
Property
Selling in 2026: How to de‑risk your agent choice and protect tens of thousands at settlement
Choosing the wrong selling agent isn’t just an inconvenience — it’s a balance‑sheet risk. In a market where digital discovery is concentrated and AI is recasting how listings are priced and promoted, ...Read more
Property
Rate resilience in Australian housing: why scarce supply is overpowering monetary tightening
Australia’s housing market is defying higher borrowing costs because the binding constraint isn’t demand—it’s supply. Brokers report persistent buyer competition and investor repositioning, while ...Read more
