Borrow
Loyalty tax
“Loyalty tax” stands as one of the hidden charges on mortgage-holders who could be blindly loyal to their bank and paying for it without even knowing it.
Loyalty tax
“Loyalty tax” stands as one of the hidden charges on mortgage-holders who could be blindly loyal to their bank and paying for it without even knowing it.
According to CGIO Finance owner Cara Giovinazzo, this misguided loyalty could be costing borrowers tens of thousands of dollars by needlessly accepting higher interest rates on their home loans.
Long-term home loan customers could be hit with a loyalty tax by their lenders, who could then be offering much lower rates to new customers for the exact same home loan product, the Queensland-based finance broker explained.
“A lot of lenders are offering much lower rates for new customers than they are for their existing mortgage-holders, despite consumers having years of loyalty with their bank. An Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) mortgage price inquiry in 2018 estimated that an existing borrower with an average-sized mortgage could initially save up to $850 a year in interest if they were to pay the same interest rate as a new borrower,” Ms Giovinazzo said.
“Despite record-low official interest rates at the moment, nothing has changed. Some mortgage-holders continue to be paying a much higher rate than what new customers are paying. After years of loyalty, this is how their lenders are treating them.
“We often see lenders offering new customers interest rates up to 1 per cent lower than they are offering some of their long-term borrowers, which could end up costing tens of thousands of dollars over the life of their home loan.”
For this reason, she strongly advised mortgage-holders to be vigilant about their home loans, particularly with the economic uncertainty due to the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic.
The finance broker encouraged borrowers to engage with trusted mortgage brokers in order to get a full view of the charges that will come with their home loan, as well as the other options available for them in the market.
“Don’t be complacent and just ‘set and forget’ as this can potentially cost you a lot of money. You need to be prepared to shop around to make sure you are getting the best terms possible,” she concluded.
“Good mortgage brokers will call their client’s banks on their behalf annually to ensure they are still on a competitive rate. They have more bargaining power with lenders typically, than if a consumer went directly to the lender themselves. Consult a reputable and experienced mortgage broker to find the lowest interest rate that suits you and to ensure you will be continually looked after.”
RELATED ARTICLES
Loans
Mortgage stress is easing — but the credit cycle’s next winners will be data‑led
New Roy Morgan data shows the share of borrowers at risk has fallen to the lowest point since early 2023. That’s a welcome inflection after two years of rate rises—but the absolute number of at‑risk ...Read more
Loans
Beyond the mortgage: SME lending is where growth, margin and loyalty are shifting
SME credit is moving from branch desks to APIs, from collateral to cashflow, and from monoline lenders to embedded platforms. For banks, fintechs and brokers, this is not a side-bet—it’s where ...Read more
Loans
Debunking credit myths leads to big wins with transparent hardship design
New research from Arca’s CreditSmart initiative surfaces a stubborn problem: Australians under financial strain are avoiding hardship support because they fear lasting damage to their creditRead more
Loans
No-deposit home loans in Australia: The growth gambit that tests risk discipline
A new no-deposit mortgage has landed in Australia, promising to crack the hardest nut in housing—fronting a deposit—while raising old questions about risk and capital. For lenders, the product doubles ...Read more
Loans
Rate relief ignites a mortgage scramble — and a technology arms race
Australia’s rate easing has flipped mortgage demand from ‘defend and retain’ to ‘originate and grow’. Refinance waves and a rekindled purchase market are colliding with digitisation, broker dominance ...Read more
Loans
Trust is the moat: How brokers can win in an AI-accelerated, commoditised mortgage market
In an evolving mortgage landscape where algorithms are levelling the playing field, Australian mortgage brokers are finding that trust, rather than price or speed, is becoming their most valuable ...Read more
Loans
CreditSmart revolutionises hardship support and lenders risk missing out
Australians under cost‑of‑living pressure are sidestepping hardship help because they fear a permanent stain on their credit file. Arca’s CreditSmart initiative has thrust this misconception into the ...Read more
Loans
Australia’s 40‑year mortgage moment: affordability optics, lifetime cost, and the new risk calculus
Forty‑year home loans are shifting from niche to feature in Australia, led by challenger banks and mutuals courting first‑home buyers. The headline promise—lower monthly repayments—masks a material ...Read more
Loans
Mortgage stress is easing — but the credit cycle’s next winners will be data‑led
New Roy Morgan data shows the share of borrowers at risk has fallen to the lowest point since early 2023. That’s a welcome inflection after two years of rate rises—but the absolute number of at‑risk ...Read more
Loans
Beyond the mortgage: SME lending is where growth, margin and loyalty are shifting
SME credit is moving from branch desks to APIs, from collateral to cashflow, and from monoline lenders to embedded platforms. For banks, fintechs and brokers, this is not a side-bet—it’s where ...Read more
Loans
Debunking credit myths leads to big wins with transparent hardship design
New research from Arca’s CreditSmart initiative surfaces a stubborn problem: Australians under financial strain are avoiding hardship support because they fear lasting damage to their creditRead more
Loans
No-deposit home loans in Australia: The growth gambit that tests risk discipline
A new no-deposit mortgage has landed in Australia, promising to crack the hardest nut in housing—fronting a deposit—while raising old questions about risk and capital. For lenders, the product doubles ...Read more
Loans
Rate relief ignites a mortgage scramble — and a technology arms race
Australia’s rate easing has flipped mortgage demand from ‘defend and retain’ to ‘originate and grow’. Refinance waves and a rekindled purchase market are colliding with digitisation, broker dominance ...Read more
Loans
Trust is the moat: How brokers can win in an AI-accelerated, commoditised mortgage market
In an evolving mortgage landscape where algorithms are levelling the playing field, Australian mortgage brokers are finding that trust, rather than price or speed, is becoming their most valuable ...Read more
Loans
CreditSmart revolutionises hardship support and lenders risk missing out
Australians under cost‑of‑living pressure are sidestepping hardship help because they fear a permanent stain on their credit file. Arca’s CreditSmart initiative has thrust this misconception into the ...Read more
Loans
Australia’s 40‑year mortgage moment: affordability optics, lifetime cost, and the new risk calculus
Forty‑year home loans are shifting from niche to feature in Australia, led by challenger banks and mutuals courting first‑home buyers. The headline promise—lower monthly repayments—masks a material ...Read more
