Borrow
Westpac’s win a ‘test case’ for responsible lending
With yesterday’s news that Westpac was deemed not in breach of responsible lending guidelines, the court judgment has outlined ASIC’s failed attempt to pin down the major bank.
Westpac’s win a ‘test case’ for responsible lending
With yesterday’s news that Westpac was deemed not in breach of responsible lending guidelines, the court judgment has outlined ASIC’s failed attempt to pin down the major bank.
nestegg reported on the allegations before the Federal Court that Westpac had breached responsible lending laws in the assessment of 260,000 approved home loans between 2011 and 2015.
Originally, the bank had admitted to breaching its responsible lending obligations and agreed to a penalty payment of $35 million, with that joint request placed before the court.
It was this application that ultimately resulted in yesterday’s decision to dismiss the application by Justice Perram, who cited reasoning that the alleged breach was not grounded in fact.
“The act does not operate as ASIC alleges” was how the Federal Court judge began his remarks.
Justice Perram said it was enough to say that as far as the consumer’s financial position is concerned, “the act requires a credit provider to ask itself only whether ‘the consumer will be unable to comply with the consumer’s financial obligations under the contract’ or, alternatively, whether the consumer ‘could only comply with substantial hardship’.”
The judge accepted that the act requires a credit provider to ask the consumer about their financial situation and, in turn, to ask itself whether compliance would be possibly using one of the two questions above.
However, he did not accept that “this had the further consequence that the credit provider must use the consumer’s declared living expenses in doing so”.
Going as far as to call out the act’s silence on how a credit provider is to answer the compliance questions, Justice Perram considered that the act contains no express statement as to how institutions should carry out such checks, nor could such a requirement to look at an individual’s declared living expenses be implied as a necessary part of a lender’s consideration.
“One may ask what knowing that a consumer currently spends $500 per month on wine tells one about whether the consumer can afford the repayments on a proposed $2 million loan, or whether, whilst able to afford to make the repayments on that loan, the consumer could do so only by being placed in circumstances of substantial hardship,” the judgment continued.
This was “a case about the operation of the responsible lending laws without any allegation of irresponsible lending”, Justice Perram summarised, as he said there were no individual events or cases evidenced by ASIC to show that Westpac had engaged in irresponsible lending behaviour.
Westpac reaction
In response to the ruling, Westpac’s chief executive for the consumer division, David Lindberg, said the bank has “always sought to lend responsibly to customers and takes its lending obligations very seriously”.
“We welcome the clarity that today’s decision provides for the interpretation of responsible lending obligations,” he continued.
ASIC’s response
Hours after the decision was handed down, ASIC also responded, and noted the “test case” status of the decision.
ASIC commissioner Sean Hughes said ASIC is carefully reviewing the judgment, and explained that the regulator “took on the case against Westpac because of the need for judicial clarification of a cornerstone legal obligation on lenders”.
“As a regulator, it is our role to test the law and its ambit,” he continued.
“The obligation to assess loan applications builds on the requirement for banks to make inquiries about a borrower’s financial circumstances and capacity to service a loan and to verify the information that borrowers give banks”.
RELATED ARTICLES
About the author
About the author
Banking
Banks urged to embrace existing payment technologies over AI hype
In the rapidly evolving landscape of financial technology, the focus has increasingly shifted towards artificial intelligence (AI) as the next frontier for innovation. However, Ian Boyd, General ...Read more
Banking
EMEA banks enjoy profit growth amid revenue challenges in 2025
In a year marked by economic turbulence and geopolitical uncertainties, the largest banks across Europe, the Middle East, and Africa (EMEA) have reported a paradoxical trend: shrinking or stagnant ...Read more
Banking
Australian major banks demonstrate resilience amid economic uncertainty
In the face of economic headwinds, Australia's major banks have reported robust half-year results, showcasing their resilience amid rising uncertainty. According to KPMG’s Australian Major Banks Half ...Read more
Banking
RBA's new ruling on card surcharges sparks debate among businesses and banks
In a significant move aimed at enhancing transparency and fairness in the Australian payments landscape, the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) has announced the removal of surcharging on debit, prepaid, ...Read more
Banking
Australian SMBs lose two business weeks annually to late payments, report finds
In a startling revelation, the latest report by GoCardless, a global bank payment company, highlights the crippling impact of late payments on small and medium businesses (SMBs) across AustraliaRead more
Banking
Brighten’s reverse‑mortgage bet: why a niche product could be non‑banks’ next profit engine
Brighten has created a dedicated reverse‑mortgage leadership post, signalling a strategic push into equity release as Australia’s demographic curve tilts older and wealth concentrates in housingRead more
Banking
Why banks are moving at different speeds after the RBA hike — and how to turn timing into advantage
The Reserve Bank’s latest cash rate move has triggered an uneven response from lenders — a pattern that reveals more about funding structures, risk appetites and systems readiness than headline ...Read more
Banking
ANZ’s company-borrower mortgage clampdown: a risk reset with wide spillovers for SMEs, investors and non-banks
ANZ has tightened credit settings for home loans where the borrowing entity is a company — a narrow policy change with broad commercial consequences. It signals a shift in risk appetite across ...Read more
Banking
Banks urged to embrace existing payment technologies over AI hype
In the rapidly evolving landscape of financial technology, the focus has increasingly shifted towards artificial intelligence (AI) as the next frontier for innovation. However, Ian Boyd, General ...Read more
Banking
EMEA banks enjoy profit growth amid revenue challenges in 2025
In a year marked by economic turbulence and geopolitical uncertainties, the largest banks across Europe, the Middle East, and Africa (EMEA) have reported a paradoxical trend: shrinking or stagnant ...Read more
Banking
Australian major banks demonstrate resilience amid economic uncertainty
In the face of economic headwinds, Australia's major banks have reported robust half-year results, showcasing their resilience amid rising uncertainty. According to KPMG’s Australian Major Banks Half ...Read more
Banking
RBA's new ruling on card surcharges sparks debate among businesses and banks
In a significant move aimed at enhancing transparency and fairness in the Australian payments landscape, the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) has announced the removal of surcharging on debit, prepaid, ...Read more
Banking
Australian SMBs lose two business weeks annually to late payments, report finds
In a startling revelation, the latest report by GoCardless, a global bank payment company, highlights the crippling impact of late payments on small and medium businesses (SMBs) across AustraliaRead more
Banking
Brighten’s reverse‑mortgage bet: why a niche product could be non‑banks’ next profit engine
Brighten has created a dedicated reverse‑mortgage leadership post, signalling a strategic push into equity release as Australia’s demographic curve tilts older and wealth concentrates in housingRead more
Banking
Why banks are moving at different speeds after the RBA hike — and how to turn timing into advantage
The Reserve Bank’s latest cash rate move has triggered an uneven response from lenders — a pattern that reveals more about funding structures, risk appetites and systems readiness than headline ...Read more
Banking
ANZ’s company-borrower mortgage clampdown: a risk reset with wide spillovers for SMEs, investors and non-banks
ANZ has tightened credit settings for home loans where the borrowing entity is a company — a narrow policy change with broad commercial consequences. It signals a shift in risk appetite across ...Read more
