Borrow
Big banks vs BNPL: What happens next?
Making sense of the big banks’ latest move into BNPL and Afterpay’s attempt to bite back.
Big banks vs BNPL: What happens next?
Making sense of the big banks’ latest move into BNPL and Afterpay’s attempt to bite back.
With major banks fully embracing the appeal of Buy Now, Pay Later apps, the pressure is on.
Wealth Within chief analyst Dale Gillham said that while the war between Australia’s biggest banks and Buy Now, Pay Later operators is heating up, it’s been something of a slow burn.
“The big four banks are good at sitting back and watching others take the risk to develop a market before entering, and this is very much what they have done in the BNPL space,” he said.
Recent months have seen more and more traditional Australian banks put their own spin on zero-interest and instalment-based credit.
“Two weeks ago, Westpac joined CBA in offering a zero-interest credit card aimed squarely at the same marketplace as Afterpay.
“Given this, I suspect it won’t be too long before ANZ and NAB join the party,” Mr Gillham predicted.
Meanwhile, market leader Afterpay has taken steps towards becoming more like a bank with the launch of its new Money app.
Despite this, Mr Gillham is sceptical that it’s enough of a reason for those who hold shares in the company to double-down.
“While I commend Afterpay for releasing this new product, now is not the time to enter this stock,” he said.
According to him, lending remains an area where the banks have a distinct advantage over brands like Afterpay.
“It is one thing to provide a service where individuals can buy an item and pay for it over a month, but Gen Z and millennials also need to be able to borrow for housing and other loans,” he said.
Mr Gillham added that the increased scrutiny towards the BNPL sector from regulators is another potential boon for traditional banks.
“Another advantage the banks have is that they are already regulated with well-established compliance systems,” he said.
“That said, the banks can be old, stale and slow to move as they are all big elephants with old systems, while the BNPL space is the new frontier,” he added.
Mr Gillham argued that ASIC has made it clear that they are looking into regulating this market, “which is likely to add red tape for BNPL organisations, resulting in reduced profit margins”.
While the “obvious winner” of increased and ongoing competition between the big banks and BNPL will be consumers, investors may also come away ahead if they play their cards right.
“Right now, while some of the stock prices for the BNPL providers are not doing very well, I would still watch this space given that in 2022, it is likely we will see some nice movement, especially with the larger providers,” Mr Gillham predicted.
RELATED ARTICLES
About the author
About the author
Banking
Brokers own the mortgage funnel: Why a 77% share is reshaping bank strategy in Australia
Australia’s mortgage market has quietly consolidated around one gatekeeper: the broker. With brokers facilitating roughly 77% of new home loans, distribution power has migrated from bank branches to ...Read more
Banking
Commonwealth Bank leads consideration while People First Bank tops satisfaction in YouGov’s latest rankings
In a revealing snapshot of Australia's banking landscape, the Commonwealth Bank (CBA) has emerged as the most considered financial institution among prospective customers, according to YouGov's ...Read more
Banking
End of the easing: what a major bank’s call signals for Australian balance sheets
A major Australian bank now argues the Reserve Bank’s rate-cut run has hit a pause, resetting the risk-free rate narrative across corporate Australia. The Reserve Bank of Australia’s latest Statement ...Read more
Banking
Open banking, real returns: How an Australian brokerage turned CDR data into deal velocity
Open banking is no longer a whiteboard theory—it’s a working growth engine. This case study unpacks how a mid-sized Australian brokerage (“Pink Finance”) operationalised Consumer Data Right (CDR) data ...Read more
Banking
Open banking’s quiet revolution: how one broker’s data play rewrites speed, trust and margin
Open banking is shifting from compliance cost to commercial engine, and early adopters in Australia’s broking market are already monetising the curve. The playbook: consented bank-grade data piped ...Read more
Banking
Open banking in action: An early adopter’s playbook—and the ROI case for Australian brokers
Open banking is shifting from conference buzzword to operational backbone in Australia’s broking sector. Early adopters are using bank-grade data and AI to compress underwriting cycles, cut compliance ...Read more
Banking
Australian brokerage pedals ahead using consented data for a speedy advantage
Open banking is no longer a concept; it is an operating model shift changing how brokers originate and package credit. Australia’s early movers, backed by the Consumer Data Right (CDR) and a ...Read more
Banking
BOQ’s mortgage squeeze is a market signal: where banks will win next as competition bites
Bank of Queensland’s shrinking home-loan book is more than a single-institution story; it’s a barometer of how Australia’s mortgage market is being rewired by broker power, non-bank agility and ...Read more
Banking
Brokers own the mortgage funnel: Why a 77% share is reshaping bank strategy in Australia
Australia’s mortgage market has quietly consolidated around one gatekeeper: the broker. With brokers facilitating roughly 77% of new home loans, distribution power has migrated from bank branches to ...Read more
Banking
Commonwealth Bank leads consideration while People First Bank tops satisfaction in YouGov’s latest rankings
In a revealing snapshot of Australia's banking landscape, the Commonwealth Bank (CBA) has emerged as the most considered financial institution among prospective customers, according to YouGov's ...Read more
Banking
End of the easing: what a major bank’s call signals for Australian balance sheets
A major Australian bank now argues the Reserve Bank’s rate-cut run has hit a pause, resetting the risk-free rate narrative across corporate Australia. The Reserve Bank of Australia’s latest Statement ...Read more
Banking
Open banking, real returns: How an Australian brokerage turned CDR data into deal velocity
Open banking is no longer a whiteboard theory—it’s a working growth engine. This case study unpacks how a mid-sized Australian brokerage (“Pink Finance”) operationalised Consumer Data Right (CDR) data ...Read more
Banking
Open banking’s quiet revolution: how one broker’s data play rewrites speed, trust and margin
Open banking is shifting from compliance cost to commercial engine, and early adopters in Australia’s broking market are already monetising the curve. The playbook: consented bank-grade data piped ...Read more
Banking
Open banking in action: An early adopter’s playbook—and the ROI case for Australian brokers
Open banking is shifting from conference buzzword to operational backbone in Australia’s broking sector. Early adopters are using bank-grade data and AI to compress underwriting cycles, cut compliance ...Read more
Banking
Australian brokerage pedals ahead using consented data for a speedy advantage
Open banking is no longer a concept; it is an operating model shift changing how brokers originate and package credit. Australia’s early movers, backed by the Consumer Data Right (CDR) and a ...Read more
Banking
BOQ’s mortgage squeeze is a market signal: where banks will win next as competition bites
Bank of Queensland’s shrinking home-loan book is more than a single-institution story; it’s a barometer of how Australia’s mortgage market is being rewired by broker power, non-bank agility and ...Read more
