Borrow
Big banks push for BNPL regulations
The success of consumer take-up and the ease of credit provided by the buy now, pay later sector have seen the major banks renew calls for tighter restrictions on their products, an inquiry heard.
Big banks push for BNPL regulations
The success of consumer take-up and the ease of credit provided by the buy now, pay later sector have seen the major banks renew calls for tighter restrictions on their products, an inquiry heard.

During a House of Representatives economics hearing, which covered a range of topics including the buy now, pay later (BNPL) service, CEOs from Commonwealth Bank and ANZ called for new regulations on the financial sector.
Providers of BNPL financing, which allows customers to pay for purchases through interest-free instalments, are not required to conduct credit checks due to not charging interest on payments. Instead they collect late payment fees and rely on taking a percentage of merchant sales, with the sector essentially governing its own code of conduct.
BNPL popularity with Millennial and Gen Z customers especially has seen Afterpay’s market cap grow to $37 billion, while its closest competitor ZIP currently has a market cap of $5.17 billion.
With changing consumer demands seeing customers prefer to split payments, Commonwealth Bank said it will launch its own buy now, pay later (BNPL) service through its debit or credit card from mid-2021.

With 4 million Aussies predicted to be using the service, Commonwealth bank CEO Matt Comyn told federal MPs that it’s time for Australians to be properly protected, calling for the platforms to be obliged to run credit checks on their customers.
“They are exempt from the comprehensive credit reporting regime and the consumer data right. They are a credit product, they are considered a credit product. They actually rely on an exclusion that was drafted many years before the category actually existed,” he said.
The CEO pointed out that if the companies were regulated by the same comprehensive credit reporting that banks and other financial players fall under, the banks would be able to understand how much debt consumers have spent on BNPL services.
According to Mr Comyn, this would allow the banks to better understand their customers and lower the risks on other financial products including credit cards and mortgages.
“I don’t think it’s unreasonable given the size of the market, the scale of the individual players — in one instance being an ASX20 company — to make an investment in understanding their customers’ circumstances and financial position,” Mr Comyn said.
ANZ’s CEO, Shayne Elliott, shared similar sentiments about the BNPL sector, calling for the financial instruments to have the same oversights as the banks.
When asked if BNPL regulation was appropriate, Mr Elliott stated “I wasn’t aware there was any”.
While he conceded that BNPL firms were innovative in their approach to the market, taking share from the banks, he said it was time to regulate it like any other form of credit.
“I don’t think because of what label I put on something, that we should be treated differently by regulation. I look at it and think what they’re doing is extending credit, and I think they therefore should be subject to the same rules as everybody else,” he said.
“Fair enough, you’ve got to where you are with some regulatory arbitrage, and now it’s time to play with the rest of the market and do so under full regulation.”
Mr Elliott also opined the proportion of customers that struggle to manage their repayments was higher for BNPL than for bank credit cards, suggesting that is due to the banks doing their due diligence on their customers.
About the author

About the author


Banking
AMP Bank GO adds business overdraft to mobile platform for small businesses
AMP Bank has launched a business overdraft feature within its mobile-first banking platform AMP Bank GO as cash flow concerns continue to affect small business owners across Australia. Read more

Banking
Bendigo Bank named most trusted bank in Australia for 10th consecutive quarter
Bendigo Bank has retained its position as Australia's most trusted bank, according to the latest trust rankings released by research firm Roy Morgan. Read more

Banking
Account-to-account and instant payments set to reshape global payments landscape
A new report from Capgemini predicts that instant payments will account for 22% of all non-cash transactions globally by 2028, signaling a major shift in the payments industry. Read more

Banking
Powell's Jackson Hole speech to shape market expectations on rate cuts
All eyes are on Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell's upcoming speech at the Jackson Hole symposium, as investors anxiously await clues about the central bank's future rate decisions. Read more

Banking
Bendigo Bank economist forecasts stable rates for 2024, cuts in 2025
Bendigo Bank's Chief Economist David Robertson is maintaining his prediction that the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) will keep interest rates unchanged throughout 2024, with cuts likely to begin in ...Read more

Banking
Hawkish central bank expectations dampen market sentiment, boosting dollar
Recent economic data and central bank communications have dampened the market's appetite for risk assets, leading to a stronger US dollar and a pullback in commodities and equities, according to Ipek ...Read more

Banking
Bank of England expected to provide guidance on future rate cuts at today's MPC meeting
European and UK stocks are outperforming their US counterparts due to a combination of factors, including high valuations in the US, strong corporate earnings from European companies, and expectations ...Read more

Banking
Investors advised to prepare for central bank policy divergence, says deVere CEO
The Bank of England, European Central Bank (ECB), and US Federal Reserve are set to take different paths in their monetary policies, which will significantly impact investors around the world, ...Read more

Banking
AMP Bank GO adds business overdraft to mobile platform for small businesses
AMP Bank has launched a business overdraft feature within its mobile-first banking platform AMP Bank GO as cash flow concerns continue to affect small business owners across Australia. Read more

Banking
Bendigo Bank named most trusted bank in Australia for 10th consecutive quarter
Bendigo Bank has retained its position as Australia's most trusted bank, according to the latest trust rankings released by research firm Roy Morgan. Read more

Banking
Account-to-account and instant payments set to reshape global payments landscape
A new report from Capgemini predicts that instant payments will account for 22% of all non-cash transactions globally by 2028, signaling a major shift in the payments industry. Read more

Banking
Powell's Jackson Hole speech to shape market expectations on rate cuts
All eyes are on Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell's upcoming speech at the Jackson Hole symposium, as investors anxiously await clues about the central bank's future rate decisions. Read more

Banking
Bendigo Bank economist forecasts stable rates for 2024, cuts in 2025
Bendigo Bank's Chief Economist David Robertson is maintaining his prediction that the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) will keep interest rates unchanged throughout 2024, with cuts likely to begin in ...Read more

Banking
Hawkish central bank expectations dampen market sentiment, boosting dollar
Recent economic data and central bank communications have dampened the market's appetite for risk assets, leading to a stronger US dollar and a pullback in commodities and equities, according to Ipek ...Read more

Banking
Bank of England expected to provide guidance on future rate cuts at today's MPC meeting
European and UK stocks are outperforming their US counterparts due to a combination of factors, including high valuations in the US, strong corporate earnings from European companies, and expectations ...Read more

Banking
Investors advised to prepare for central bank policy divergence, says deVere CEO
The Bank of England, European Central Bank (ECB), and US Federal Reserve are set to take different paths in their monetary policies, which will significantly impact investors around the world, ...Read more