subscribe to our newsletter sign up

Shots fired: Courts, ATO send strong message to taxpayers in latest ruling

Supreme Court of Queensland

In a stern warning to taxpayers who get creative with their paper trail, a Queensland local was sentenced to seven years jail after “cooking the books” for his wife’s business.

The facts of the case

Stephen Mungomery has been sentenced in the Brisbane District Court to seven years jail time and ordered to pay reparations of more than $1.2 million.

Between March 2009 and October 2012, Mr Mungomery lodged 46 business activity statements (BAS) on behalf of his wife’s business, Gourmet Providores Pty Ltd.

In each BAS lodgement, Mr Mungomery included expenses incurred by his sole trader entity Epicure Consulting and Training Solutions (Epicure).

Smelling a rat


When the ATO asked Mr Mungomery to produce the invoices to substantiate the claims, Mr Mungomery produced 24 Epicure-issued invoices with a total of $13,767,466 in sales ($1,253,511 GST inclusive).

The invoices were for a range of costs including $5 million for website development and more than $2.6 million for franchise development. These invoices accounted for 92 per cent of all expenditure, did not bear any commercial reality and were never paid.

The ATO’s investigators further discovered that the initial website developed for Gourmet Providores Pty Ltd was actually created by a different company at a cost of $7,885. Mr Mungomery’s franchise development claims were also found to be fraudulent.

Warning shots fired

ATO assistant commissioner Peter Vujanic said that it was astounding that anyone thought they could get away with such brazen fraud.

“This wasn’t an honest mistake by a small business owner trying to do the right thing — it was a calculated and deliberate attempt to commit fraud and steal money from taxpayers,” Mr Vujanic said.

“This kind of illegal behaviour takes away potential tax dollars from the Australian community, which could otherwise go to essential infrastructure services such as roads, schools and hospitals.

“As this case demonstrates, if you’re caught breaking the law, we will hold you accountable, even if it means pursuing you in the criminal judicial system.”


Shots fired: Courts, ATO send strong message to taxpayers in latest ruling
Supreme Court of Queensland
nestegg logo
subscribe to our newsletter sign up
Recommended by Spike Native Network
Neil - I retired about a year ago and now I've got less income than I planned for. Can I sue my financial planner?....
Joe - Agree with Terry Dwyer. The really nasty part is the way it will hit self funded retirees (through their SMSF in many cases) who have direct shares.......
John - Not sure loss of 30% of income is something I just let go. Options I will be doing is investing overseas, local and international REITs and seeing if.......
Dr Terry Dwyer, Dwye... - I am amazed by these comments. The effects will be subtle but pervasive. It will have a huge effect on superannuitants in pension mode as with low.......