subscribe to our newsletter sign up

‘Poor and biased’ tax proposal cops a lashing

Thumbs down, poor and biased

In the face of a government-backed inquiry, Labor’s plans to scrap refundable excess dividend imputation credits has copped further backlash from one of the countrys top investment analysts.

Don Hamson, who is the managing director of fund manager Plato Investment Management, referred to Labor's franking credits proposal as “a pretty divisive policy” that is “effectively increasing taxes on self-funded retirees”.

“My opinion is it's a pretty poor and biased proposal,” Mr Hamson said.

“If you’re in a self-managed super fund, you wouldn’t get any franking credits. Because that was all pension phase, you don’t get the exemption.


“There would be incentives in that situation for someone to get out of their self-managed super fund and own the assets in their own name or put it into a super fund where they can get the franking credits.”

Mr Hamson's comments come as the House of Representatives standing committee on economics announced an inquiry into the implications of removing refundable franking credits.

In March, Opposition Leader Bill Shorten proposed that individuals would no longer be able to claim cash refunds on franking credits that had not been applied to offset tax liabilities.

The abolition of the benefit, according to Mr Shorten, would result in an additional $5.6 billion to the federal budget bottom line.

Even if Labor wins the next election, Mr Hamson said it would be difficult to get the crossbench support required in the Senate to implement its franking credit proposal.

“As we've seen with the company tax policy of the current government, they couldn't get that through the Senate because it didn’t get approval by all the small groups and the Greens,” he said.

“[Senator] Pauline Hanson is against this policy and the Greens are against this policy, so it's going to be tough I think to get through the Senate.”

‘Poor and biased’ tax proposal cops a lashing
Thumbs down, poor and biased
nestegg logo
subscribe to our newsletter sign up
Recommended by Spike Native Network
Neil - I retired about a year ago and now I've got less income than I planned for. Can I sue my financial planner?....
Joe - Agree with Terry Dwyer. The really nasty part is the way it will hit self funded retirees (through their SMSF in many cases) who have direct shares.......
John - Not sure loss of 30% of income is something I just let go. Options I will be doing is investing overseas, local and international REITs and seeing if.......
Dr Terry Dwyer, Dwye... - I am amazed by these comments. The effects will be subtle but pervasive. It will have a huge effect on superannuitants in pension mode as with low.......